• Home
  • About
    • What’s happening here
    • Greg Sandow
    • Contact
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Sandow

Greg Sandow on the future of classical music

Not so much power?

June 8, 2016 by Greg Sandow

I’ve read some things about what Yannick might do as the Met’s music director, when finally he starts that job.

(Can’t stop myself from calling the guy what the Philly Orchestra calls him, though I’ve never met him, and couldn’t in my wildest dreams imagine that I’d write about Muti and call him “Riccardo.” The power of marketing for a new era!)

yannick blogIn some of what I’ve read, there seems to be an assumption that Yannick will have a lot of power.

But I wonder. In most US orchestras, the big ones, anyway, the music director has a more restricted role than many people know. Isn’t in town all that much, may only plan the concerts he or she conducts. I know one top American orchestra where one music director, who reigned for several years (and was internationally famous), had nothing to do with the orchestra’s new music initiatives.

And at another top orchestra, an incoming music director, also a world-famous name, told the artistic director not to ask him about the choice of guest conductors. He didn’t hear many conductors, this music director said, so in most cases wouldn’t have an opinion.

What will Yannick be involved in?

One thing music directors do, and it’s important, is to play a role in hiring musicians. And thus shaping the sound of the orchestra. I assume Yannick will do that at the Met, no doubt expertly.

But will he help choose guest conductors? Help cast the operas? Will he make (or have a role in) artistic decisions of a kind that we don’t often hear about, but which have to be made? I’m thinking of things like whether to use a new critical edition of a score, or which version to choose of operas whose composers gave them more than one form (like Idomeneo or Tales of Hoffman).

Or which cuts to make in an oversized bel canto score like Anna Bolena or Semiramide.These decisions have to be made. Will Yannick — with a title that suggests he’s ultimately responsible for all the music played and sung at the Met — make these choices, or be involved in them? Even if he’s not conducting the productions?

What I’d like to see

My guess, about the question I’ve just asked, is that the answer will be no. I hope I’m wrong. Would be lovely to see a unified artistic vision at the Met. Which also might extend to making sure that some conductors conduct in ways quite different from Yannick’s, so we get many kinds of musicmaking.

But here’s one small thing I’d like. In the past, I’ve noticed taht the Met orchestra could at times sound pretty bad — even though they’re basically terrific — when Levine wasn’t conducting.

I noticed this in productions of bel canto works, where maybe the conductor was an Italian-opera specialist the musicians didn’t think had enough conducting chops. And when maybe the musicians didn’t respect the score.

i’m guessing about those things. Though they’re things that can happen. And in the 1980s, when I was much involved in opera, a member of the Met orchestra told me how much she hated playing Bellini, because she thought he wasn’t a good composer.

I’d love Yannick — or any Met music director — to get involved here. To tell the orchestra the virtues of Bellini, and their special role in Italian operas, even those with what seeems to be simple orchestration. They have to breathe and phrase with the singers, and set the tone of arias, even when they just play a few oompahs before the singer starts.

Yannkick also — on my wish list — would know how the orchestra plays when he’s not around. And if they don’t meet their highest standard, would tell them so (in no uncertain terms). And would tell them that no matter what they think of a conductor, they have to do their best.

I wonder if these things will happen. There’s one clear obstacle. Yannick can’t hear every conductor who comes to the Met, because he’ll often be away. Will he care enough to let someone else be his eyes and ears? And will he act on what he’s told?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Greg Sandow

Though I've been known for many years as a critic, most of my work these days involves the future of classical music -- defining classical music's problems, and finding solutions for them. Read More…

About The Blog

This started as a blog about the future of classical music, my specialty for many years. And largely the blog is still about that. But of course it gets involved with other things I do — composing music, and teaching at Juilliard (two courses, here … [Read More...]

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSS

Archives

@gsandow

Tweets by @gsandow

Resources

How to write a press release

As a footnote to my posts on classical music publicists, and how they could do better, here's a post I did in 2005 -- wow, 11 years ago! --  about how to make press releases better. My examples may seem fanciful, but on the other hand, they're almost … [Read More...]

The future of classical music

Here's a quick outline of what I think the future of classical music will be. Watch the blog for frequent updates! I Classical music is in trouble, and there are well-known reasons why. We have an aging audience, falling ticket sales, and — in part … [Read More...]

Timeline of the crisis

Here — to end my posts on the dates of the classical music crisis  — is a detailed crisis timeline. The information in it comes from many sources, including published reports, blog comments by people who saw the crisis develop in their professional … [Read More...]

Before the crisis

Yes, the classical music crisis, which some don't believe in, and others think has been going on forever. This is the third post in a series. In the first, I asked, innocently enough, how long the classical music crisis (which is so widely talked … [Read More...]

Four keys to the future

Here, as promised, are the key things we need to do, if we're going to give classical music a future. When I wrote this, I was thinking of people who present classical performances. But I think it applies to all of us — for instance, to people who … [Read More...]

Age of the audience

Conventional wisdom: the classical music audience has always been the age it is now. Here's evidence that it used to be much younger. … [Read More...]

Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in