• Home
  • About
    • What’s happening here
    • Greg Sandow
    • Contact
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Sandow

Greg Sandow on the future of classical music

Out of the past

October 20, 2005 by Greg Sandow

I was in Tower Records the other day, and they were playing the opening chorus of what turned out to be the Klemperer recording of Bach’s B Minor Mass. It was slow and massive, moving (if it could be said to move at all) without a trace of what we now understand to be Baroque rhythm. Nobody, I think, could do Bach that way today. Some people would laugh, others would groan.

Then, later the same day, I was listening to a 1955 Charles Munch recording of Beethoven’s Pastoral Symphony, and could barely believe the liner notes. They were by Louis Biancolli, who back then the music critic of the New York World-Telegram and Sun (and, as it happened, a friend of my parents). I could barely believe what I was reading:

In the heart of every music-lover there is a cherished place for the “Pastoral” Symphony of Beethoven. Should some malign occult power ever banish it from our midst, it would leave an aching void in the artistic consciousness of the world. Ever since its premiere in 1808, the “Pastoral” has been the great revelation of Nature in music. To it have come those seeking refreshment and strength and escape. Here, for some precious forty minutes, they have found a healing power for the torment of spirit and the stress of daily living. Those who have learned to love every measure of this monument to the outdoors have come to cherish still more the message of profound solace and beauty that Beethoven gleaned from the smiling face of Nature. And this is as it should be — and as Beethoven willed it. For him Nature was more than a seasonal pageantry of marvels to hear and to see; in the gathering turmoil and turbulence of the years it had become the great healer, the center of repose, the confidante. Flowers, clouds, running brooks, forests of firs, rolling vistas of green spoke to this troubled pilgrim of the countryside. At times it was of man they spoke, of his immemorial dream of world brother­hood and love; at more sublime moments they were the very voice of God. “What sovereignty in a forest like this!” he exclaims. “On the heights there is rest — to serve Him.”

And so on. Nobody — at least nobody with any prominence — would write like that today. Anyone who did would be laughed out of the business faster than someone who conducted Bach like Klemperer.

And yet haven’t we lost something? What Klemperer and Biancolli have in common is conviction, and above all deep and honest feeling. Music matters to them. You can groan at Klemperer’s remorseless, heavy pace, but when the main theme shows up in the bass, it’s so huge and deep that it seems to rise from the depths of the earth. Maybe that’s not something Bach ever dreamed of (though didn’t his organ pedals go down to the lowest depths?), but it’s powerful. You can smile, or wince, at Biancolli’s gushing, but doesn’t he try, at least, to touch the powerful emotion in the piece? And simply by trying (and doing a decent, if old-fashioned job of it), doesn’t he come about a thousand miles closer to the real Beethoven than all the careful scholarly, historical, analytical, and (the new trend) lightly anecdotal notes we’re getting now?

Filed Under: main

Greg Sandow

Though I've been known for many years as a critic, most of my work these days involves the future of classical music -- defining classical music's problems, and finding solutions for them. Read More…

About The Blog

This started as a blog about the future of classical music, my specialty for many years. And largely the blog is still about that. But of course it gets involved with other things I do — composing music, and teaching at Juilliard (two courses, here … [Read More...]

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSS

Archives

@gsandow

Tweets by @gsandow

Resources

How to write a press release

As a footnote to my posts on classical music publicists, and how they could do better, here's a post I did in 2005 -- wow, 11 years ago! --  about how to make press releases better. My examples may seem fanciful, but on the other hand, they're almost … [Read More...]

The future of classical music

Here's a quick outline of what I think the future of classical music will be. Watch the blog for frequent updates! I Classical music is in trouble, and there are well-known reasons why. We have an aging audience, falling ticket sales, and — in part … [Read More...]

Timeline of the crisis

Here — to end my posts on the dates of the classical music crisis  — is a detailed crisis timeline. The information in it comes from many sources, including published reports, blog comments by people who saw the crisis develop in their professional … [Read More...]

Before the crisis

Yes, the classical music crisis, which some don't believe in, and others think has been going on forever. This is the third post in a series. In the first, I asked, innocently enough, how long the classical music crisis (which is so widely talked … [Read More...]

Four keys to the future

Here, as promised, are the key things we need to do, if we're going to give classical music a future. When I wrote this, I was thinking of people who present classical performances. But I think it applies to all of us — for instance, to people who … [Read More...]

Age of the audience

Conventional wisdom: the classical music audience has always been the age it is now. Here's evidence that it used to be much younger. … [Read More...]

Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in