• Home
  • About
    • CultureCrash: The Blog
    • Culture Crash: The Book
    • Scott Timberg
    • Contact
  • Culture Crash: The Book
    • Culture Crash: The Book
    • Book Events
  • Other AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

CultureCrash

Scott Timberg on Creative Destruction

Working for Free, Pro and Con

June 25, 2014 by Scott Timberg

[contextly_auto_sidebar id=”3yEpOmVWqQdiM8tHRZQ892WnlfCfPiSE”]

AMAZINGLY, there are still gurus urging creatives that working for free — for for-profit companies — is a good “branding” move. An article in the Financial Times describes some who believe in the great opportunities of the digital age, and says that asking for — and receiving — free labor has continues to increase.

But as these trends have become more entrenched, the backlash has become more fierce. The blogosphere is replete with much-tweeted tirades from those who have simply had enough. Some workers have deployed their creative talents to denounce the practice, for example by producing witty manifestos and flow-charts to help you decide whether to accept commissions for no pay. A much-shared email exchange by humorist David Thorne ad­dresses the debate. Other detractors have even embraced their own motto: “If you’re good at something, never do it for free,” as spoken by Batman’s nemehoskyns-waitingsun-coversis The Joker in the film The Dark Knight.

The piece describes the stop-working-for-free fight waged by British music journalist Barney Hoskyns — whose history of Los Angeles music, Waiting for the Sun, is absolutely first-rate. Says Hoskyns: “If you allow yourself to be seduced by the myth that your unpaid labour will ‘look good on your CV’, try to see that you jeopardise not only the welfare of your replaceable elders but your own long-term future.” You’ve basically said that your work has no value.

The whole notion that we should give our work away — in some ways the logical end-point of the “information wants to be free” movement — spells very bad short- and long-term implications for the creative class.

Filed Under: "Free", creative class, culture business models, Internet, rock music

Comments

  1. Eb Witherspoon says

    June 26, 2014 at 5:46 am

    Depends on the context. If someone is trying to gain experience when they are new to a field, or trying to pad their CV, they are essentially in training–and the person training them is in a sense working on THEIR behalf for free. Internships, for example, are increasingly paid because they have been perceived as unfair “free labor.” But often the experienced person finds his or her work SLOWED DOWN by the intern–and the experienced person finds him or herself having to MAKE WORK for the intern–an added responsibility. It’s a two-way street, not entirely one-sided.

  2. Scott Timberg says

    June 26, 2014 at 9:08 am

    Sure, but we’re not really talking about internships here. Hoskyns’ movement is about experienced professionals being asked to write or do other work for nothing — usually for companies making money off their labor.

    • Daniel Levenstein says

      June 26, 2014 at 12:28 pm

      A musician friend of mine once commented, after being asked to perform in exchange for the exposure: “You know, people DIE of exposure!”

Scott Timberg

I'm a longtime culture writer and editor based in Los Angeles; my book "CULTURE CRASH: The Killing of the Creative Class" came out in 2015. My stories have appeared in The New York Times, Salon and Los Angeles magazine, and I was an LA Times staff writer for six years. I'm also an enthusiastic if middling jazz and indie-rock guitarist. (Photo by Sara Scribner) Read More…

Culture Crash, the Book

My book came out in 2015, and won the National Arts & Entertainment Journalism Award. The New Yorker called it "a quietly radical rethinking of the very nature of art in modern life"

I urge you to buy it at your favorite independent bookstore or order it from Portland's Powell's.

Culture Crash

Here is some information on my book, which Yale University Press published in 2015. (Buy it from Powell's, here.) Some advance praise: With coolness and equanimity, Scott Timberg tells what in less-skilled hands could have been an overwrought horror story: the end of culture as we have known … [Read More...]

Follow Me

Follow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSSFollow Us on E-mail

Archives

@TheMisreadCity

Tweets by @TheMisreadCity
June 2014
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« May   Jul »

An ArtsJournal Blog

Recent Posts

  • Scott Timberg Has Passed Away
  • Ojai Music Festival and JACK Quartet
  • What’s in a Name?
  • Time Pauses For Valentin Silvestrov
  • The Perverse Imagination of Edward Carey

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in