For last Saturday’s performance of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony at the Round Top Music Festival, an orchestra of 88 gifted young musicians rehearsed for 22 hours over the course of six days; there were also more than four hours of sectional rehearsals. A splendid young Austrian conductor, Christoph Campestrini, used every minute of his allotted time, correcting and exhorting with precision and enthusiasm. The result was formidable: an impassioned and idiomatic account, honed to honor Mahler’s kaleidoscopic textures.
The previous week, Round Top offered a performance of the original, unabridged version of Rachmaninoff’s little-heard Fourth Piano Concerto with a world-class soloist: Eteri Andjaparidze. Other symphonic programs his summer include an homage to Diaghilev (Poulenc, Respighi, Stravinsky), Roussel’s The Spider’s Feast, and Christopher Rouse’s Flute Concerto alongside more standard fare. The chamber concerts (with faculty artists) are a cornucopia of delicacies: the composers include Faure, Poulenc, Ligeti, Enescu, and Schoenberg (the Chamber Symphony No. 1).
The Round Top musicians are selected by blind audition from schools and conservatories across the US. The average age is 22. They spend six weeks at Round Top on full scholarship. The faculty of 44 – I took part for a week as a Mahler lecturer – includes principal players from prominent American orchestras. As Round Top, Texas, is in the middle of nowhere – both Austin and Houston are more than an hour away — a sense of community is assured.
The festival’s longtime program director, Alain Declert, is an inimitable yet much imitated Frenchman charmingly disposed to vehement opinion. The founder and artistic director is the pianist James Dick, whose civility and warmth pervade the premises. Incredibly, he conceived the notion of a music festival in Round Top fully forty years ago. Two years later, a large portable outdoor stage was moved to Round Top from Minnesota. The current 1,000-seat concert hall is acoustically distinguished and architecturally unique.
What the Round Top oasis portends for its gifted beneficiaries is a good question. There are far more aspirants than orchestral jobs in the world outside. One can only hope that orchestras and musicians alike will find ways to think constructively about institutions and instrumentalists whose responsibilities must and will expand in the decades ahead. #
Mahler in Texas
June 27, 2011 by Leave a Comment

Recent Comments
Joel Lee on A Status Report on City Opera
Again, we go on and on about the acoustics at the NY State Theater. Why were there not criticisms...william osborne on A Status Report on City Opera
Small music theater requires entirely new concepts of composition, singing and staging. NYCO wants to create a new form...Chuck Lavazi on Dvorak and Hiawatha
The first time I heard the Largo of the Dvorak 9th (then called the 5th, which shows what a geezer...Robert Berger on Ives the Sophisticate
Interesting article, but your dismissal of the Sibelius 2nd as "banal" and "cliched" could not be more...Mark Stryker on Ives the Sophisticate
Joe, Insightful post, thanks. Interestingly, in a review I wrote a couple days ago about the four Ives symphonies played at...J. Theakston on The Greatest Film Score You’ve Never Heard
Must disagree with you on one point, Joe. Modern accompaniment for classic films (silent films excluded) is walking a...richard on The Met’s New Parsifal
I saw the performance of March 5, and your description of the brillance of this production rings true. At last,...Geo. on The Met’s New Parsifal
I saw the HD-cast of this production rather than in person, so obviously my perspective is limited that way. ...msirt on The Met’s New Parsifal
Ah ha! I finally "get" François Girard's final interpretive thrust for this rendition : Parsifal's words (paraphrase of the poem):...Sixtus Beckmesser on The Met’s New Parsifal
Thank you for this thoughtful and insightful appraisal. I was fortunate to have seen the HD broadcast on Saturday,...