Amazing, heartening followup to my recent post, about my students' ideas for what should have happened in Cleveland. I'm told that the Detroit Free Press, back in the '80s, actually did what my students recommended. Their critic back then gave bad reviews to the music director of the Detroit Symphony, who at that time was Gunther Herbig. That wasn't a comfortable situation, and symphony supporters made a fuss to the newspaper's publisher. But instead of caving in, the paper did something wonderfully smart and honorable. It brought in three … [Read more...]

Yesterday, in my Juilliard class on music criticism, we talked about the critic mess in Cleveland. And two of my students, Vanessa Fralick and Ethan van Winkle, had really good ideas. They noted, as we all did, that it's really disgraceful for the Cleveland Plain Dealer to demote Don Rosenberg, its respected classical music critic, just because they're uncomfortable with his negative reviews of the Cleveland Orchestra's music director. The fullest, most plausible defense of what they did is in a column by Ted Diadiun, the paper's reader … [Read more...]

A week ago Saturday, October 5, the Wall Street Journal ran an essay by Leon Botstein, college president and conductor. Title? "The Unsung Success of Live Classical Music." Theme? Classical music is healthy, and not at all declining. Content? One myth after another. I couldn't post about this here, because I didn't have time. But the myths have to be exploded. For instance: ...looking out at the audience at most classical music concerts in the United States, one sees a crowd that is largely middle-aged, verging on the geriatric. This has … [Read more...]

We're back -- my wife Anne Midgette and I have finished our whirlwind three-day residency at the College of Music at Florida State University. Anne, as of course I've said here many times, is the chief classical music critic at the Washington Post. We had a terrific time. And then, as soon as I got back, I conferred intently with people from a notable music school, and then had a performance of my music. But more on those things later.What Anne and I (and in a couple of cases one of us separately) did at FSU:    • spoke to … [Read more...]

I was listening to Il giuramento, an opera by Mercadante, the top dog among 19th century Italian opera composers whose work hasn't survived in the repertoire. He writes smooth melodies, whips up at least the appearance of drama, and expertly handles every aspect of the 19th century Italian style. So what's missing? I'd put it this way -- his characters never grab you, singing (as a subtext to whatever their words are) "I am somebody!" (To borrow Jesse Jackson's phrase.) Listen, by contrast, to just about any Verdi aria. Verdi's characters are … [Read more...]

I loved the comments on my recent post on opera titles. They built a safety net under my limited Italian, provided wonderful examples of the things I was talking about, and took my ideas a lot further. And I want to sent a happy shout to Cori Ellison, who commented, who works professionally with titles, and provides a point of view that the rest of us don't have. It all makes me want to state, or restate, some general points.First, it strikes me that we tend to think of titles as purely explanatory, a neutral element in an opera performance. … [Read more...]

A New York Times story says today that the New York City Opera will lay off 11 full-time employees. That's 13% of their staff. The company, as quoted in the story, says it needs fewer staff members this year because, well, basically the company won't be giving any normal performances. And there's of course an economic factor, too. Says a spokesman, quoted by the Times, the company "believes that this reorganization will position the opera to deal with current economic conditions." This leads to a cascade of questions. Did the company need … [Read more...]

I have a piece on Berlioz's operas in the new issue of Opera News. You can read it online here. It was fun to write -- I didn't know Benvenuto Cellini well, and didn't know Béatrice et Bénédict at all. Was very surprised to find out that B&B is a dud, in spite of a ravishing duet at the end of the first act. (Which has nothing to do with the plot -- one sign of the things that make the opera a dud, at least for me.) Among the many delights I had was listening to the first Colin Davis recording of Cellini, which I think is one of the great … [Read more...]

From one of my wife Anne Midgette's terrific pieces on Christoph Eschenbach in the Washington Post: He has long ago discarded the standard tailsuit in favor of a crisp Nehru jacket; at the Orchestre de Paris, where he is music director...a fashion house was brought in to design an alternative to the players' traditional formal dress.So it can be done, unless the players and audience in Paris just hate what they're wearing now. Any word on that?(Anne's other Eschenbach piece is here.)Added later: I searched online in vain for photos of the … [Read more...]