Final word on North Korea?

We Americans can theorize all we like, but there’s something most of us don’t have — the ghastly experience of living under a totalitarian regime. James Zhu, who had that experience, posted the following as a comment to my North Korea posts. He fully supports the Philharmonic’s visit, and wrote what follows as a response to my fellow blogger Terry Teachout’s piece in the Wall Street Journal. Terry opposed the Philharmonic’s visit, which of course he has every right to do.

I thought I’d promote James Zhu’s thoughts from a comment to a full blog post. I feel humbled before what he says. Thanks, James.

Following is a post in response to Terry Treachout article on WSJ 10/27. Since part of Treachout article, which strongly against the visit, is a refute to you view, I repost here.

I was a bit unsettled by your article on New YorK Philharmonic visit  toNorth Korea, 10/27/2007, on WSJ. You never lived in such a “Darkness at Noon”, nothing less) and culture, how do you evaluate the impact of classic music to people “not familiar with Western composers”? I was first exposed to Mozart at a time when one of my school teachers was beaten to death on the street like a wild dog. I didn’t quite understand what was going on, but through his Serenade I said to myself, “there are got to be a better world”.  I was timely punished and sent away to a camp for scavenging these Columbia 33 1/2 records and listening to them.

After Philadelphia Philharmonic came to China(the audience was highly controlled and not telecasted), nobody over there thought it was a support to Mao, knowing you wouldn’t be raided on anymore if you listen to Duke Ellington, and knowing the more good stuff were coming. I surmise the viewpoints like yours must be more belligerent before Philadelphia Orch. did China. Alas, look at what happened.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on RedditEmail this to someone