Lively magazine

MUSO sent free copies to music schools when they first started. When I first saw one, my reaction, and that of many of my colleagues, was "ick." Another step in the direction of making classical music about the sex appeal of young performers, as if the art was something to be practiced only by idiot savant "spokesmodels" (remember "Star Search"?) who might also be eligible for careers in soft porn or escorting.

Could any young overweight instrumentalist develop a solo career today? Could someone who plays like Josh Bell but looks like Horatio Sanz hope for anything other than an orchestra job, if not kept from that for fear of possible health0care expense?

I respect your opinion, Greg, so there must be virtues to MUSO that I overlooked, or that have developed since I first saw it. But, really, isn't its emphasis on making it's featured artists look sexy part of the problem than part of the solution? It's like a fashion magazine for classical music kids.

Eric, I can understand your hesitation. But I think MUSO is completely respectable. There's a lot of purely musical content. And look -- they put eighth blackbird on the cover. That's not exactly glamour.

And even the glamour content -- seriously, what's wrong with that? If we want classical music firmly established in our society, we can't pretend that appearance doesn't matter, or that we're not going to have to play some of society's games. The problem, after all (at least for me), is that classical music seems stuffy and out of date. To change that perception (and the reality that goes along with it), we're going to have to give the same visual cues other things in our world give. Cues that say, "Something's happening here." Glamour is one of those cues, though there are others. MUSO seems to me to do a lot to fix this. We might not like every aspect of it, but the alternative might be extinction.

Another thought alone these lines: You can't, I think, have a thriving serious classical music world if you don't also have a thriving popular classical music world. That was always true in past centuries, when the standard repertoire was new, and I think it's just as true now. Which would be the better problem to have: That good-looking classical musicians get too much attention, or that nobody's paying attention to classical music at all?

Awww shoot- and that's definitely our most glam photo to date.

I've got to watch what I write in these comments. "eighth blackbrid -- that's not exactly glamour." What I meant, of course, was "eighth blackbird -- that's not exactly brainless glamour." It's a terrific photo, as you can see on my latest blog.entry.