Sinfonia black

The Association of British Orchestras conference I went to

was held in Newcastle, a lively, thriving city. Or pair of cities—it promotes

itself as NewcastleGateshead, Gateshead being a sister city right across the

River Tyne. I happened to spend time with two people from the UK the day before

I left, and both of them raved about how fine a place it is.

And I could see that for myself. I had a hairraising

connection between two of the three flights I had to take, to get to Newcastle,

and while I managed to get to the plane on time, my luggage didn’t. So I had the

pleasure of walking through Newcastle, looking for a chemist’s (as they say over

there), to buy some toiletries. It’s clearly a lively town; you can tell just

from looking at the people and the shops, not to mention the life sciences

center and the fabulous performing arts facility, the Sage Gateshead.

Which brings me to the Northern Sinfonia, the local

orchestra. They play in the Sage Gateshead’s main concert hall, which seats

1700, and is airy, modern, comfortable, but also has an easy elegance, and

sounds terrific. And the musicians, almost all (if not absolutely all of them)

fairly young, dress in a way that fits both the hall and the lively cities. They

wear black—without tails or fancy dresses, without even jackets or ties for the

men, if I remember correctly. I asked Anthony Sargent, who runs the facility, if

the orchestra always dresses this way, and he said they did, even when the Queen

came to a concert a month or so ago.

And that did it. As far as I’m concerned, I never want to

see an orchestra wear tails again. The Northern Sinfonia looked so crisp, so

alert, so contemporary, and at the same time so friendly…who wouldn’t want to

see musicians dressed like that? Of course, their youth fit their outfits, or

their clothes fit their youth. An older orchestra, or one less visibly enjoying

itself, might have looked out of place wearing what the Northern Sinfonia wore.

Something else to think about: the orchestra has a

late-evening new music series, which apparently attracts a sizeable young

audience. Obviously it wouldn’t make any sense to wear tails for that. But by

wearing (as I’ll guess they do) the same clothes for the new music concerts and

for their regular gigs, they help build their brand, and help make people who

come to the new music shows feel comfortable if they come to the main events.

The concert seemed well attended. The audience wasn’t

notably old, and really seems to love the orchestra. I know it’s not quite so

simple here in America; I’m sure that older subscribers might well hate it if

orchestras started dressing more informally. But it’s got to happen sometime. Do

orchestras want to look like they come from some high-church dreamland, or do

they want to be part of the world their future audience lives in?