• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
    • The Unanswered Question
    • Joseph Horowitz
  • Contact
  • ArtsJournal
  • AJBlogs

Unanswered Question

Joe Horowitz on music

Celebrating the Ives Sesquicentenary: An American Landmark

November 3, 2023 by Joe Horowitz

The upcoming Sesquicentenary of Charles Ives (1874-1954) is a landmark moment in American cultural history. Not only is he the towering creative genius of American classical music; he links to the highest American cultural pantheon, resonating in countless ways with the likes of Ralph Waldo Emerson, Mark Twain, Walt Whitman, and Herman Melville (connections I explore in my book Dvorak’s Prophecy).

Judging from the website bachtrack, Ives is today far more performed in Europe than the US. Judging from Wikipedia, he is still mis-categorized as a “modernist.” The Sesquicentenary is an opportunity to claim Ives for his American time and place: the late Gilded Age and American fin-de-siecle.

Thanks to J. Peter Burkholder, the central celebration will take place at Indiana University/Bloomington, where the Jacobs School of Music is planning a week (October 1 to 6, 2024) of contextualized concerts, cross-disciplinary lectures, and discussions supported by the NEH Music Unwound project that I direct. There will also be NEH-supported Music Unwound Ives festivals at the Brevard Music Center (mid-July, 2024), Bard College (including a Carnegie Hall concert by Bard’s The OrchestraNow – November, 2024), and Chicago (the Chicago Sinfonietta in collaboration with the Rembrandt Chamber Players and Illinois State University/Normal — mid-February, 2025).

The Bloomington festival is notable for the participation of scholars outside Music. These include a major art historian specializing in the 19th century “American Sublime” (Tim Barringer), a major Civil War historian who really knows music (Allen Guelzo), a major Gilded Age historian who can track the etymology of that troubled label (Alan Lessoff). My own contribution will juxtapose Ives with Mahler (who similarly oscillates between the quotidian and the sublime), and with Sibelius and Elgar (who similarly stopped composing, vexed by modernism and modernity, rooted in native landscapes). I already know that I will say:

“Among canonized composers of classical music, Charles Ives possesses the most elusive, least stable reputation; he remains a moving target. That at the same time he is for many the supreme American creative genius among concert composers, a figure protean and iconic, must say something about America and Ives both: as ever, we’re not sure who we are. Even our orchestras and instrumentalists perform him far less than they should.

“Ives’ first reputation, congealing midway through the twentieth century, was framed by modernists who pedigreed ‘originality.’ Ives’ ‘experiments’ in tonality and rhythm were compared with those of Arnold Schoenberg – whose music he did not know. This obsession with ‘who got there first?’ pigeonholed Ives as an intriguing historical anomaly rather than an expressive genius. It placed him firmly in play, but proved essentially patronizing.

“Once the modernist criterion of originality dissipated, it became possible to resituate Ives not as an anomalous victim of repressive materialistic decades, but as a complex product of a dynamic period of  American growth itself undergoing revision. Hence the sesquicentenary opportunity at hand, celebrating the 150th birthday of this most volatile cultural bellwether.” 

Share:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. William McClelland says

    November 7, 2023 at 7:55 am

    What a fabulous celebration. Thank you so much for organizing this. Best wishes for a great success!

Primary Sidebar

About Joe Horowitz

I am a cultural historian specializing in the American arts. I pursue parallel careers as a scholar/writer and concert producer. The most recent of my eleven books is Dvorak’s Prophecy and the Vexed Fate of Black Classical Music (winner of a 2022 ASCAP-Deems Taylor Award). It links to six “Dvorak’s … [more] about Joseph Horowitz

About Unanswered Question

When a few years ago Doug McLennan invited me to write an ArtsJournal blog, I thought about it and said no. Having been born as long ago as 1948, I remain somewhat a stranger to the internet. And, as I am always writing a book (a form of therapy) when I am not producing concerts, I felt I didn't … [more] about The Unanswered Question

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Rich Jensen on A Saturday Night Livestream: Lou Harrison’s Piano Concerto in South Dakota
  • William Osborne on The Cultural Cold War Revisited — and Cultural Diplomacy in Africa Today
  • William Osborne on The Cultural Cold War Revisited — and Cultural Diplomacy in Africa Today
  • William McClelland on Celebrating the Ives Sesquicentenary: An American Landmark
  • Sanda Schuldmann on A Great Present-Day Pianist

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in