• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
    • Real Clear Arts
    • Judith H. Dobrzynski
    • Contact
  • ArtsJournal
  • AJBlogs

Real Clear Arts

Judith H. Dobrzynski on Culture

What’s The Connection Between The Barnes And Hitler?

I’ve always opposed the move of the Barnes Foundation into Philadelphia, and mostly — but not unwaveringly — agreed with the Friends of the Barnes Foundation. But the Friends have goofed, I think, in a very distasteful way. It’s time to call them on it.

Last week, they sent me a link to a “New Barnes video” on YouTube. It’s not a snippet — it’s nearly four minutes long and someone, or some bodies, spent time on this. It uses an old film of a raging Hitler — apparently from a German film called “The Downfall” and which I gather has been used many times “in jest” — trying to pull off a great art heist. When he loses his own officers, Hitler decides to call the Pew Trust, which helped orchestrate the Barnes move.

Given all the good reviews the new Barnes has been getting (it opened with a trumpet fanfare), it’s clear the Friends are feeling low, but standing pat. On Friday night, during the opening gala, and on Saturday night, they had planned to wear black and stand in protest at the new Barnes to “witnesses to the destruction of the Barnes Foundation.” Presumably they did, though I’ve seen no mention of that in the press –another slight by hometown newspapers, which back the move.

And, the Friends have been fined by the court, probably unfairly, and are still protesting and fighting that.

But the Hitler video isn’t funny and is way out of proportion.

Last week, I suggested to one of the Friends, “Maybe it’s time to call it a day?” Their efforts, it seems to me, have nowhere to go. The Barnes has moved, and it’s not going back to Merion.

“Calling it a day depends mostly on an assessment of whether or not there is any justice to be had and the risks of putting the system to the test,” she wrote back.

That is true. Someone, in some court, may agree that they should not have to pay penalties for using the courts. I just wish they had remained on the high road. What’s the connection between the Barnes and Hitler? None, absolutely none.

Photo Credit: Courtesy of the Friends of the Barnes Foundation

 

Richard Amstrong Gets A Chair — At His Old Museum

To my mind, the creation of an endowed curatorial position at a museum doesn’t make news. But here’s an exception: on Friday, the Carnegie Museum of Art announced that an endowment had been created for the position of curator of contemporary art. Lynn Zelevansky also announced the appointment of the museum’s Associate Curator of Contemporary Art Dan Byers (below left), who is co-curating the 2013 Carnegie International, to this new position.

Then came the twist: the chair has been named in honor of another museum’s director — Richard Armstrong (below right), director of the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum and Foundation and previous head of the Carnegie.

It’s a hearty compliment to Armstrong, who left Pittsburgh for his current post in 2008 after 12 years as director of the museum and four as a curator there. When he left, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazettequoted museum board Chairman William E. Hunt saying “Physically and financially, it’s in as good a shape as it has been in a very long time,” praised his expansion of the museum as well as his people skills, and added, “We have a world class group of curators. He’s done a tremendous job with his management group as well as his educators. He has also made strategic and intelligent acquisitions.”

The Carnegie didn’t say how much money has been raised for the chair or from whom. But there’s one clue on the website: Announcing the fourth annual Art in Bloom — “a four-day celebration of timeless art and fresh flowers, presented by the Women’s Committee of the Carnegie Museum of Art” — it said that proceeds from it will “benefit the Women’s Committee dedicated gift for the Richard Armstrong Curator of Modern and Contemporary Art Endowed Chair.” That gift has been disclosed as $500,000, though it’s unclear if all has been raised or not. Or where else money for this endowment is coming from.

In any case, I can’t think of a similar gesture toward a living former director. (Let me know if there are others.)

Armstrong’s tenure at the Guggenheim has had its ups and downs, it compliments and criticisms, which is to be expected. Here’s hoping that it ends, whenever that is, with as good a feeling in New York as Pittsburgh has for his tenure there.  

Photo Credit: Courtesy of the Post-Gazette (top)

 

New “Mill and Cross” Book Reveals More About “Way To Calvary”

To my own regret, I did not see the recent film, “The Mill and The Cross,” filmmaker Lech Majewski’s 2011 restaging of Peter Bruegel’s 1564 masterpiece, “The Way to Calvary.” Adapted from the 2001 book by independent art critic Michael Francis Gibson (who also co-wrote the screenplay), it won raves.

More happily, I am now in the possession of a new edition of the original book — and it’s stunning. Published in English, French (at left) and German (University of Levana Press), the book contains a two-page spread of the whole painting, plus 130 details from every part of it. It also offers new material, “including stills from the film, photos of the shooting,” and — better yet — “a number of as yet unpublished details hidden deep inside the painting – aspects of what might rightly be termed the invisible Bruegel.” [their boldface, not mine] More about which in a minute.

First, I want to highlight what Gibson says at the start, that as a child he hated being told what to think of a painting before he’d seen it. He suggests: “Perhaps you shouldn’t read this book just yet. Why not look at the pictures first. Get acquainted with them. Step into their world without preconception.”

Brilliant — I so agree, always or almost always.  With his book, I did just that — and the details are delicious. Separate paintings, all of them. The painting is, as Gibson says, “a gigantic miniature.” My only complaint is that even with a two-page spread of the original, it’s hard to pinpoint where the details are located on the picture. Readers could have used some sort of key, perhaps an overlay of the numbered detail outlines on a copy of the painting in the back.

Now to the new details, which I cite even though I’m still looking at details, mostly, and haven’t read the book, except to dip in here and there. In the publisher’s billing, we hear:

As Gibson explained, he was looking at some close-up photos provided by the Kunsthistorishes Museum, when he was stunned to discover that a hundred or more original paintings lay concealed inside the larger one. One of these in particular impressed him.

“If you look to the right of the mill on its impropable rock,” he says, “you will find a sunless moor and a little man leaning into the wind and trudging up the hill towards a splash of sunlight at the top. But what took my breath away was the realization that Bruegel had taken the pains to paint in a light rain falling aslant on the moor. At which point I thought to myself, ‘that little rain has been falling up there for close to 450 years, but I may be the first to have seen it since Bruegel set down his brush.’ (Publisher’s comment; It turns out that the curators of Flemish paintings, who have ample opportunity to examine the painting at close quarters are indeed aware of the falling rain…)

You can see, sort of, what he’s talking about above right.

None of us will ever get as close to the painting as Gibson did — which he writes was “perched on a stool with a magnifying glass in my hand and my nose five inches away from Bruegel’s Way to Calvary.” Our only alternative is to buy this book.

Photo Credits: Courtesy of University of Levana Press (bottom)

Curators Name Award-Worthy Exhibitions and Catalogues

Now for some awards, these just announced by the Association of Art Museum Curators. Recognition by one’s peers is the highest form of praise, really, as they should know the true values of a profession and pay little heed to popularity. 

Outstanding Catalogue Based on an Exhibition (tie):

Gifts of the Sultan: The Arts of Giving at the Islamic Courts, Los Angeles: Los Angeles County Museum of Art, 2011, by Linda Komaroff, Sheila Blair, Jonathan Bloom et. al.

and:

Pacific Standard Time: Los Angeles Art 1945-1980, Los Angeles: Getty Publications, 2011, by Rebecca Peabody, Andrew Perchuk et. al.

Outstanding Catalogue Based on a Permanent Collection

Fragonard’s Progress of Love at The Frick Collection, New York: The Frick Collection in association with D Giles Limited, 2011, by Colin B. Bailey.

Outstanding Catalogue Essay:

Randall R. Griffey, Curator of American Art, Mead Art Museum, Amherst College, “Reconsidering ‘The Soil'”: The Stieglitz Circle, The Regionalists and Cultural Eugenics in the Twenties,” in Teresa A. Carbone, et al., Youth and Beauty: Art of the American Twenties, exh. cat. (Brooklyn, NY: Brooklyn Museum, 2011), 245-77.

Outstanding Monographic or Retrospective Exhibition

“Alexander McQueen: Savage Beauty,” curated by Andrew Bolton, The Costume Institute at the Metropolitan Museum of Art (pictured above)

Outstanding Thematic Exhibition

“The Steins Collect: Matisse, Picasso, and the Parisian Avant-Garde,” co-curated by Janet Bishop of SFMOMA, Cécile Debray for the Reunion des Musées Nationaux-Grand Palais, Rebecca Rabinow of the Metropolitan Museum of Art of Art, and Gary Tinterow, formerly of the Metropolitan Museum of Art

Outstanding Exhibition in a University Museum

“It Happened at Pomona: Art at the Edge of Los Angeles 1969-1973,” curated by Rebecca McGrew, Pomona College Museum of Art and Glenn Phillips, Getty Research Institute, at Pomona College Museum of Art

 Outstanding Permanent Collection New Installation (or Re-installation)

“Artist’s Eye, Artist’s Hand: American Indian Art,” curated by Nancy Blomberg, Chief Curator and Curator of Native Arts, Denver Art Museum 

Outstanding Small Exhibition (based on square footage: no more than 2,000 square feet)

“Antico: The Golden Age of Renaissance Bronzes,” curated by Eleonora Luciano, associate curator of sculpture, National Gallery of Art, in collaboration with Denise Allen, curator of Italian sculpture, The Frick Collection, New York, and Claudia Kryza-Gersch, Curator of the Kunstkammer, Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, at the National Gallery of Art, Washington (above, right).

The complete press release, with all authors named and some runners-up, is here.

I’m especially pleased by the award to the Denver Art Museum, whose installation, which added attribution to Native American artists wherever possible, I wrote about in The New York Times and here, here and here.

I don’t have any other real comments — I liked all of those honored that I saw — except to note again that these choices seem to favor the east and west coasts.

Photo Credits: Courtesy of the Met (top) and the Frick (bottom)

Roy Lichtenstein Exhibition Opening Delayed — Due To Popular Demand

Is this a first? We are quite used to having museums add evening hours for a popular exhibition, staying open all night in the final days, and even extending the run by a few days.

But the Art Institute of Chicago has done the opposite — delayed the opening of its Roy Lichtenstein exhibition, which was supposed to be tomorrow, thanks to popular demand of its members. Now the opening of Roy Lichtenstein: A Retrospective is slated for May 22. (The museum is closed May 19-21 because of the NATO summit in Chicago.)

As is usual practice, the Art Institute opened the exhibit of about 160 drawings, paintings and sculptures first to members. But more than 3,000 signed up for the preview opportunities, and lectures, which can accommodate up to 1,000 people, also filled up fast. The three planned days for members had to be stretched.

Could it be that Lichtenstein is that popular? Or did the recent record price at auction, $44.9 million for Sleeping Girl (left), which isn’t in the show, add to the attraction?

One-year memberships cost $80, and offer other opportunities to view the show, like pre-opening hours on weekends.

If you can’t get there, you might try the “explore the exhibition” website the Art Institute has created. Some aspects, like the slider feature showing the relationship between his drawings and paintings, are pretty cool.

 

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

About Judith H. Dobrzynski

Now an independent journalist, I've worked as a reporter in the culture and business sections of The New York Times, and been the editor of the Sunday business section and deputy business editor there as well as a senior editor of Business Week and the managing editor of CNBC, the cable TV

About Real Clear Arts

This blog is about culture in America as seen through my lens, which is informed and colored by years of reporting not only on the arts and humanities, but also on business, philanthropy, science, government and other subjects. I may break news, but more likely I will comment, provide

Archives