• Home
  • About
    • diacritical
    • Douglas McLennan
    • Contact
  • Other AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

diacritical

Douglas McLennan's blog

Trump, The Tenor, And Fascism

August 4, 2016 by Douglas McLennan 5 Comments

Over on Slate this week Brian Wise posted a piece about Donald Trump and his playing of Puccini’s Nussun Dorma at campaign events. Trump had been using a recording of Pavarotti singing the aria and the singer’s family had contacted him to ask him to stop.

Musicians have been complaining for years about politicians using their music at events without permission, and it’s always fun to ridicule a pol with whom you disagree when the artist whose work they’ve chosen to associate themselves with repudiates the “honor.”

So Wise writes:

Trump’s use of it might read as yet more evidence for those who already view the bombastic businessman as a fascist in the making… Not only is Turandot an opulent, Orientalist fantasy set in imperial China by a composer who never set foot in Asia; Puccini also held a sympathetic spot in his heart for the fascist Italian dictator Benito Mussolini. The composer’s late-career admiration for Mussolini’s policies has prompted a new generation of historians to see his operas—especially Turandot—through a political lens.

It is “quite easy to read Turandot as a political allegory,” writes Arman Schwartz in the book Puccini’s Soundscapes, “one consistent with fascism’s own narrative of the degradation of post-World War I Italy and of Mussolini’s heroic rise.”

While I applaud the urge to dump on Trump (for so many reasons), trying to associate him with fascist sympathies because his campaign plays one of the most famous arias on the planet is a yuge overreach. Trump is essentially historically context-free. He grabs things and uses them (facts, images, music, ideas, tweets) because they are shiny objects that caught his attention in that jumbled stream-of-consciousness river that flows through his head. The backstory is irrelevant to him.

He uses a Star of David in an ad on Hillary Clinton because it’s a star and he didn’t stop to think it might have more specific meaning. He thinks US obligations to NATO allies are dependant on allies’ behavior because he’s unaware of the history. And he uses Puccini because it sounds heroic to him. Powerful. Not because it resonates with the fascist child within. Debates about connections between artists’ political views and their work have raged for years. But when you’re as devoid of context as Trump is, a song is but a song…

Share:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: arts and politics

Comments

  1. william osborne says

    August 4, 2016 at 5:58 pm

    One of the most salient characteristics of Fascism is its embrace of political opportunism. Power is the end in itself and should be obtained by any means necessary. Any populist rhetoric that will move one toward power is embraced.

    This is one of the reasons that it is difficult to define Fascism. Its proponents typically espouse any view that will help them gain power, and then abandon it when it is no longer politically useful. An example of the inconsistencies that follow is how Hitler was supported by reactionaries, but called his party National Socialism.

    From this perspective, Trump’s erratic and inconsistent embrace of populist themes to increase his power is classic Fascist methodology. Sometimes he grabs onto ideas that are actually important, such as the disenfranchisement of American labor, but instead of genuinely pursuing those themes, he has no real concern about them. He drops them the minute he finds a new pet topic with which he can manipulate the media. If he were a better and more experienced Fascist politician, he would consistently hammer on populist themes. Good Fascists know the value of heavily repeated propaganda.

    Sadly, empty populist rhetoric and fear mongering are a central part of even mainstream American politics. Trump’s use is just more obvious and crass.

    Hitler’s Machiavellian appeals to populist emotion were extremely effective. The German counter-reaction to those methods after the war shape the country’s culture to this day as manifested in a deep suspicion of overt emotionalism even in the arts. They virtually equate overt emotionalism with Fascism. One example is their concepts of contemporary classical music holds to a stubbornly dry, objective modernism.

    Reply
    • william osborne says

      August 4, 2016 at 6:27 pm

      I forgot to mention that I don’t equate Puccini with Fascism. Puccini’s emotions might be a bit inauthentic and over the top, but that doesn’t make them evil. The artistic exploration and representation of emotion can help us understand human identity, but for Fascists emotions are merely a means to malignant ends outside of art and emotion. We cannot abandon emotion in art because it leaves us vulnerable to manipulation. Both good and evil can be strengthened by emotion. We must express our emotions intelligently and morally. Keep the Puccini, dump Trump.

      Happy to see Brian Wise back at work.

      Reply
      • Douglas McLennan says

        August 5, 2016 at 1:01 pm

        As you say – classic fascism. My point isn’t that he isn’t a fascist – or that fascist ideas don’t resonate with him. I’m just saying that drawing connections to what may or may not have been fascist sympathies of the composer and believing they are implicit in this aria was Trump’s coded reason for choosing it is a stretch.

        Reply
        • william osborne says

          August 5, 2016 at 4:48 pm

          True. I doubt Trump was even behind the decision to use the aria. Probably some campaign manager.

          Reply
          • william osborne says

            August 5, 2016 at 6:25 pm

            BTW, Stravinsky was also a big fan of Mussolini. I think the Rite of Spring would work very well for some of Trump’s rallies, especially if he got some of his colleagues from Wrestle Mania to join in the presentations.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Douglas McLennan

I’m the founder and editor of ArtsJournal, which was founded in September 1999 and aggregates arts and culture news from all over the internet. The site is also home to some 60 arts bloggers. I’m a … [Read More...]

About diacritical

Our culture is undergoing profound changes. Our expectations for what culture can (or should) do for us are changing. Relationships between those who make and distribute culture and those who consume it are changing. And our definitions of what artists are, how they work, and how we access them and their work are changing. So... [Read more]

Subscribe to Diacritical by Email

Receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,820 other subscribers
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSSFollow Us on E-mail

Archives

@AJDoug

Tweets by @AJDoug

Recent Comments

  • Sam Hodak on Too Many Artists Or Not Enough Value?: “So what you’re telling me is… make a VR experience” May 12, 00:03
  • Mark on What If Disruption Was Just A Tech Con Game?: “Thank you” Mar 19, 13:15
  • Douglas McLennan on Still Amusing Ourselves to Death: Information as Cautionary Tale: “Hi John: Yes – remember over the last decade how Big Data was going to change everything and drive every…” Nov 26, 07:46
  • John McCann on Still Amusing Ourselves to Death: Information as Cautionary Tale: “I haven’t read this book, yet your review triggered an insight about information shared within organizations and how so much…” Nov 26, 03:57
  • Richard Voorhaar on The UnderTow: The High-flying Oil Industry fears “Demand Destruction.” Should the Arts?: “We have reached the point where the average American has no attention span. A 3-4 minute pop tune is all…” Jun 10, 11:22
  • Alan Harrison on The UnderTow: The High-flying Oil Industry fears “Demand Destruction.” Should the Arts?: “Brilliant piece, Doug. It’s why, in my own columns on LinkedIn and Medium, I may have become more strident recently…” Jun 8, 15:46
  • Tom Corddry on The UnderTow: The High-flying Oil Industry fears “Demand Destruction.” Should the Arts?: “Slick analogy. Social scientists estimate that 95% of everything we do is basically done out of habit, because it’s an…” Jun 7, 21:04
  • sandi kurtz on The UnderTow: Subscriptions are the New Business Model of Choice. So Why are Subscriptions Failing in the Arts?: ““As for seat licenses in the arts – I think it doesn’t work unless demand is so spectacular you can…” Jun 1, 23:19
  • Douglas McLennan on The UnderTow: Subscriptions are the New Business Model of Choice. So Why are Subscriptions Failing in the Arts?: “I think the membership model is an interesting variant. And the web has gone back and forth on labeling its…” May 31, 07:42
  • Douglas McLennan on The UnderTow: Subscriptions are the New Business Model of Choice. So Why are Subscriptions Failing in the Arts?: “Thanks Gary. I originally had a section in this podcast discussing why the NYTs’ success hasn’t worked its way down…” May 31, 07:19

Top Posts

  • If Dance Can't Pay Its Dancers What Does It Mean To Be A Professional Dancer?
  • The Mass Market Ain't What It Used To Be (And What That Means For The Arts)
  • "Art Is Good?" Not Much Of An Argument For Art Is It?

Recent Posts

  • Still Amusing Ourselves to Death: Information as Cautionary Tale November 25, 2022
  • The UnderTow: What the new Edinburgh Fringe Tells us about a Post-COVID World June 26, 2022
  • The UnderTow: The High-flying Oil Industry fears “Demand Destruction.” Should the Arts? June 7, 2022
  • The UnderTow: Subscriptions are the New Business Model of Choice. So Why are Subscriptions Failing in the Arts? May 23, 2022
  • This Week’s UnderTow: Why are Police Playing Disney Songs? And Why did this Orchestra Fire its Conductor for… Conducting? April 23, 2022
August 2016
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  
« Jul   Sep »

An ArtsJournal Blog

Recent Posts

  • Still Amusing Ourselves to Death: Information as Cautionary Tale
  • The UnderTow: What the new Edinburgh Fringe Tells us about a Post-COVID World
  • The UnderTow: The High-flying Oil Industry fears “Demand Destruction.” Should the Arts?
  • The UnderTow: Subscriptions are the New Business Model of Choice. So Why are Subscriptions Failing in the Arts?
  • This Week’s UnderTow: Why are Police Playing Disney Songs? And Why did this Orchestra Fire its Conductor for… Conducting?

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in