• Home
  • About
    • diacritical
    • Douglas McLennan
    • Contact
  • Other AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

diacritical

Douglas McLennan's blog

John: A Misunderstanding and Two Questions

December 17, 2006 by Douglas McLennan Leave a Comment

Doug:
I think we’re talking about different things with the word “rules.” I meant that for each individual, critic or otherwise, there should be no rigid, exclusionary standards that determine our positions about most anything. With conflicts of interest and objectivity, I meant by no rules that to take an extreme position may be fun to write and fun to read, but does not correspond to the way things really are. Life is a common-sense compromise, a solid nourishment to which the wilder passions and polemical positions lend necessary spice.
You seem to be thinking of newspaper conflict-of-interest policies by the word rules. I agree they are often silly and prissy and pompous and contradictory. Though when I was interim classical music and dance critic for the Oakland Tribune in the first half of 1969 (Paul Hertelendy was on a six-month academic fellowship art Stanford), one of my first Sunday pieces argued that the Tribune should pay for critics’ tickets, books and LP’s. The mad purism of youth. The Tribune killed the column.
But I won’t go so far as you do at the end of your most recent post, and argue that “there’s no such thing as conflict.” Entanglements, unknown or even known, do affect the critic and they do affect the reader. But hey, no rules: everyone has to work out a comfortable place along that continuum for himself. Or herself.
So Doug, I have two questions for you; answer both or one or neither.
The first is born of our shared involvement with the newly reborn National Arts Jounalism Program. Aside from writing criticism or assembling compilations of criticism, how would you best advocate for the imperiled cause of serious arts journalism? And not just the criticism of the higher arts, but serious criticism of all the arts, high and low, Western and world. Would you stress the ideal virtues of Art and the intelligent discussion thereof; or the economic impact of an arts community, including critics, on a city; or education? And to whom? To editors and publishers, in print or the Internet, to bloggers and the public, to North America or the world? What would you do? What should we do? Have a master plan or work piecemeal with funders? Start a journal? Make speeches (to whom?). Write a book? Deluge the Internet with pleas (to whom?).
My second question circles back to my book. In a recent conversation with an upper-level editor at The Times, he said his ideal critic was one who could perambulate around the Culture Dept. or even the paper, writing brightly for the (dreaded, by me) General Reader about classical music or rock or dance or film or sports or widgets, for all I know. Even though this echoes my own career — I think he was tyring to flatter me — it made me nervous.
You cited your experience as a musician and a pianist as defining your critical sensibility, nicely making the distinction between that and being a better critic. Of course, knowing the piano and its repertory doesn’t help you much with clarinet repertory or the singing voice or the polemics about operatic stage production. To what extent do you think deep, lifelong expertise in one art, or one facet of one art, is the proper goal for the young critic? Or can one jump from art to art, as I have done, counting on one’s native intelligence or accrued knowledge to substantiate your competence and hoping that your range of interests will enrich your attention to any one of them? Or do you think there are no rules (like I do!) and that there can be excellent specialist critics and excellent more broadly based critics? As long as the former know how to speak beyond their coterie and the latter know enough to be plausible, even stimulating, to specialist readers?

Share:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related

Filed Under: main

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Douglas McLennan

I’m the founder and editor of ArtsJournal, which was founded in September 1999 and aggregates arts and culture news from all over the internet. The site is also home to some 60 arts bloggers. I’m a … [Read More...]

About diacritical

Our culture is undergoing profound changes. Our expectations for what culture can (or should) do for us are changing. Relationships between those who make and distribute culture and those who consume it are changing. And our definitions of what artists are, how they work, and how we access them and their work are changing. So... [Read more]

Subscribe to Diacritical by Email

Receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,851 other subscribers
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on RSSFollow Us on E-mail

Archives

Recent Comments

  • David E. Myers on How Should we Measure Art?: “A sophisticated approach to “measuring” incorporates all of the above, with clear delineation of how each plays a part if…” Nov 3, 16:20
  • Tom Corddry on How Should we Measure Art?: “Reading this brought to mind John Cage’s delineation of different ways to experience a Beethoven symphony–live in concert, on a…” Nov 3, 01:58
  • Abdul Rehman on A Framework for Thinking about Disruption of the Arts by AI: “This article brilliantly explores how AI is set to revolutionize everything, much like the digital revolution did. AI tools can…” Jun 8, 03:49
  • Richard Voorhaar on Classical Music has Lost a Generation. Blame the Metadata (in part): “I think we’ve lost several generations. My parents generation was the last that really supported, and knre something about classical…” May 15, 12:08
  • Franklin on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “Language, yes; really characterization. Investments and margins don’t become subsidies and taxes whether or not markets “are working” – I’m…” Mar 8, 07:13
  • Douglas McLennan on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “So what you’re arguing is language? – that investments aren’t subsidies and margins aren’t taxes? Sure, when markets are working.…” Mar 7, 21:42
  • Franklin on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “Doug: You can, if you like, buy a jailbroken Android, install GrapheneOS, and sideload apps from the open-source ecosystem at…” Mar 7, 16:17
  • Douglas McLennan on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “Franklin: Thanks for the response, But a few points: My Chinese solar panel example was to make the point that…” Mar 7, 12:46
  • Steven Lavine on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “Terrific essay, with no prospect to a different future” Mar 7, 09:53
  • Franklin on How Subsidy for Big Tech Wrecked the Arts (and Journalism): “The economics of this essay are incoherent. The CCP was creating yuan ex nihilo and flooding it into domestically produced…” Mar 7, 08:49

Top Posts

  • Are Orchestras A Ticket Or An Art? Maybe We're Thinking About The (Made Up) Model Wrong
  • Is The Institutionalization Of Our Arts A Dead End?
  • We Asked: What's the Biggest Challenge Facing the Arts?
  • Creativity Versus Skills
  • The UnderTow: What the new Edinburgh Fringe Tells us about a Post-COVID World

Recent Posts

  • Creativity Versus Skills January 12, 2025
  • How Digital AI Twins could Transform how We Make Art January 7, 2025
  • How Should we Measure Art? November 3, 2024
  • Classical Music has Lost a Generation. Blame the Metadata (in part) May 13, 2024
  • When “Vacuum Cleaner for Babies” Beat Taylor Swift: Fixing the Music Streaming Problem May 6, 2024
December 2006
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
« Nov   Jan »

An ArtsJournal Blog

Recent Posts

  • Creativity Versus Skills
  • How Digital AI Twins could Transform how We Make Art
  • How Should we Measure Art?
  • Classical Music has Lost a Generation. Blame the Metadata (in part)
  • When “Vacuum Cleaner for Babies” Beat Taylor Swift: Fixing the Music Streaming Problem

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in