• Home
  • About
    • About this Blog
    • About Andrew Taylor
    • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Other AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

The Artful Manager

Andrew Taylor on the business of arts & culture

Not just subconscious, but DNA deep

January 18, 2020 by Andrew Taylor

When we talk about organizations, or other forms of collective action by groups of people, we often speak as if we have dominantly conscious control. We talk about designing the business, developing the policies, arranging the office, and building relationships. In short, we talk like architects or construction workers — agents with autonomy, attention, and control over the ways and means of our working lives.

cc flickr Pascal
cc flickr Pascal

But evidence from a range of disciplines suggests that we’re not really in conscious control of much — individually or collectively. Sure, we make what feel like decisions and we attribute them to our actions. But that may be more fiction than fact.

At the individual level, there are good indications that our conscious brain works much or most of the time justifying or contextualizing what our unconscious and sensory systems have already determined (see Daniel Kahneman or Benjamin Libet, as examples). Here, the conscious mind is the attorney, not the client.

At the collective level, there’s also good evidence that our social instincts are the product of thousands of generations of natural selection, and not (only) the product or process of a complex conscious mind. Further, there’s evidence that a wide range of non-human animals have similar instincts, because they improve evolutionary fit for many environments.

In his 2019 book, Blueprint: The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society,
sociologist/physician Nicholas A. Christakis suggests a “social suite” of eight evolutionary instincts that combine and intertwine to shape and structure all aspects of our social lives:

  • Capacity to have and recognize individual identity
  • Love for partners and offspring
  • Friendship
  • Social networks
  • Cooperation
  • Preference for one’s own group (in-group bias)
  • Mild hierarchy (uneven attribution of prestige or authority within groups)
  • Social learning and teaching

Each of these and all of these certainly connect to aspects of organizational life. We can think and speak about them as if they’re available to our direct attention and creative control. But Christakis suggests that they’re deep in our instinctual and sensory selves, rather than products of our intentions.

This doesn’t mean we avoid intentional(ish) design, discovery, action, and effort when working together. It just means we have fewer levers to fiddle with than we often claim to have. This possibility of social action that’s dominantly deeper than reason suggests that we bring extra helpings of humility, patience, and awareness to all forms of collective effort. We’re passengers more than we are pilots at the wheel.

Filed Under: main

Comments

  1. Trevor O’Donnell says

    January 22, 2020 at 12:30 am

    Your post made me think of Ayn Rand, who would have hated this. Or who would have said that there are individuals who are capable of punching through the veil and taking conscious control. I never cared for Rand or agreed with her philosophy, but this made me want to root for her heros.

    • Andrew Taylor says

      January 28, 2020 at 7:07 am

      Thanks Trevor. It would be satisfying to annoy Ayn Rand. Although I regret that the post leads you to root for her self-regarding protagonists. It is certainly disquieting to think that much of our conscious thinking is a sidecar rather than the motorcycle of our actions in the world. But it’s worth a wrestle, nonetheless.

About Andrew Taylor

Andrew Taylor is a faculty member in American University's Arts Management Program in Washington, DC. [Read More …]

ArtsManaged Field Notes

#ArtsManaged logoAndrew Taylor also publishes a weekly email newsletter, ArtsManaged Field Notes, on Arts Management practice. The most recent notes are listed below.

RSS ArtsManaged Field Notes

  • Flip the script on your money narrative June 3, 2025
    Your income statement tells the tale of how (and why) money drives your business. Don't share the wrong story.
  • The sneaky surprise of new arts buildings May 27, 2025
    That shiny new arts facility is full of promise and potential, but also unexpected and unrelenting expense.
  • The one and the many of board service May 20, 2025
    How do nonprofit boards balance individual impulse with collective resolve?
  • The relentless rise of pseudo-productivity May 13, 2025
    Visible activity and physical exhaustion are not useful measures of valuable work.
  • The strategy screen May 6, 2025
    A strong strategy demands a clear job description

Artful Manager: The Book!

The Artful Manager BookFifty provocations, inquiries, and insights on the business of arts and culture, available in
paperback, Kindle, or Apple Books formats.

Recent Comments

  • Barry Hessenius on Business in service of beauty: “An enormous loss. Diane changed the discourse on culture – its aspirations, its modus operandi, its assumptions. A brilliant thought…” Jan 19, 18:58
  • Sunil Iyengar on Business in service of beauty: “Thank you, Andrew. The loss is immense. Back when Diane was teaching a course called “Approaching Beauty,” to business majors…” Jan 16, 18:36
  • Michael J Rushton on Business in service of beauty: “A wonderful person and a creative thinker, this is a terrible loss. – thank you for posting this.” Jan 16, 13:18
  • Andrew Taylor on Two goals to rule them all: “Absolutely, borrow and build to your heart’s content! The idea that cultural practice BOTH reduces and samples surprise is really…” Jun 2, 18:01
  • Heather Good on Two goals to rule them all: “To “actively sample novel experiences (in safe ways) to build more resilient perception and prediction” is about as useful a…” Jun 2, 15:05

Archives

Creative Commons License
The written content of this blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Images are not covered under this license, but are linked (whenever possible) to their original author.

an ArtsJournal blog

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in