• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
    • Real Clear Arts
    • Judith H. Dobrzynski
    • Contact
  • ArtsJournal
  • AJBlogs

Real Clear Arts

Judith H. Dobrzynski on Culture

Michigan Beyond Detroit: The News Is … Good

Congrats to Bridge Magazine, an online journalism venture from the Center for Michigan (which describes itself as a “think-and-do tank”), for doing some enterprise arts journalism: A recent article looks at the state of museums around the state of Michigan, obviously using the hook of the woes posed by Detroit’s bankruptcy to the Detroit Institute of Arts.

FlintInstituteUsing the case of the Flint Institute of Arts (at right) as its lead, author Nancy Derringer writes:

Which may go to show that even in a blue-collar city in a blue-collar state, there is still something special about art – even as that art is potentially imperiled by cities’ fiscal implosions.

The Detroit Institute of Arts is gathering most of the media attention paid to the state’s cultural sector these days as the DIA works furiously to protect its assets from being swept up in Detroit’s municipal bankruptcy proceedings. The foreboding publicity has been good for business this summer. DIA Director Graham Beal notes that attendance was 10,000 in a recent summer week, compared to a more typical 3,000-4,000, and just 2,000 two years ago. …

Michigan’s other art museums appear to have capably weathered the recession.

Among her findings:

  • Eli and Edythe Broad Art Museum, Michigan State, where ““optimistic” annual attendance goal of 100,000 was reached in nine months.”
  • Kalamazoo Institute of Arts, where no layoffs occurred though there were salary cuts that are now “coming back.”
  • Grand Rapids, where “a new building opening in 2007, and Art Prize’s debut in 2009, kept bodies moving through the front doors.
  • Muskegon, whose museum director describes it as “a scrappy town on its best day,” is finishing an 18-month endowment drive and its staff expects to reach its $7.5 million goal easily.”
  • The Flint Institute of Arts, whose director says, “We’re doing collectively $12-13 million a year in programming, much of which is free or subsidized.”

The article mentions a few small difficulties and notes that the Muskegon museum, which “has always functioned as a part of the Muskegon Public Schools,” is now changing that:

Although the museum has a separate ownership board, it is taking no chances. The institution is going forward with plans to separate entirely from the schools in 2014.

As a sidebar, there’s a “Why Go?” piece giving particulars for each museum mentioned.

 

The article sounds a positive note on the DIA, saying “In the state’s largest city, none of the art-world specialists expect the DIA to be hollowed out by Detroit’s fiscal problems, although the perceived threat is being taken seriously.”

Let’s hope.

Photo Credit: Courtesy of Bridge

Good News: MoMA Mornings!

I’ve often written here about the need for museums to adapt their hours to today’s lifestyles — and usually that has meant a call for adding more evening hours. Most museum-goers, aside from school children, now work, I believe, and can’t get to a museum between 9 and 5 (and sometimes museums hours are even more constricted to 10 or 11 to 4!).

But, as the Museum of Modern Art just reminded me, I’ve neglected mornings. Some workdays begin at 10 a.m. nowadays. Given the opportunity, some people might stop by an urban, well-located museum on their way to work.

MoMAGardenSo MoMA is trying a variation on opening early: free access to its Sculpture Garden every morning from 9 a.m. to 10:15 a.m. That gives the museum 15 minutes to clear the garden before its galleries open, at 10:30. As MoMA writes in its press release:

Beginning September 9, The Museum of Modern Art’s Abby Aldrich Rockefeller Sculpture Garden will be open free of charge to the general public daily, from 9:00 to 10:15 a.m., allowing New Yorkers and visitors alike to start their day in one of the city’s most beloved outdoor spaces. The public can enter the Sculpture Garden directly through the west gate on West 54 Street, between Fifth and Sixth avenues. Coffee and beverages will be available for purchase.

Weather permitting, MoMA intends to offer this chance year-round.

This move is good for tourists, too: Often, they have nothing to do right after breakfast. I’ve worked (and still do) in or near Rockefeller Center and Times Square for much of my life in New York, and I often see tourists out early looking for something to do in the morning. Aside from the greenery, among the works they can now see are Barnett Newman’s Broken Obelisk (1967), Picasso’s Monument (1972) and She-Goat (1950), Katharina Fritsch’s Figurengruppe/Group of Figures (2006–08),  Miró’s Moonbird (1966), and works by Alberto Giacometti, Henri Matisse, Mark di Suvero, Tony Smith, and others.

MoMA, as you’ll remember, is now open seven days a week, just like the Met. MoMA is closed on Thanksgiving and Christmas, as is the Met, which is also closed on January 1 and the first Monday in May (not sure why that is).

Good thinking, MoMA.

Photo Credit: Courtesy of MoMA

 

 

 

Theft Alert: Looting At Egypt’s Malawi Museum, Minya

Violence in Egypt has spread to museums again, and this time it looks more serious than the thefts from the Egyptian Museum in Cairo many months back.

newsegypteA new report called a recent episode “the biggest theft to hit an Egyptian museum in living memory.” Among the losses are “a prized 3,500-year-old limestone statue, ancient beaded jewelry and more than 1,000 other artifacts.” There was human loss, too: “The museum’s ticket agent was killed during the storming of the building, according to the Antiquities Ministry.”

MinyaMuseumLootingHere’s more:

The scale of the looting of the Malawi Museum in the southern Nile River city of Minya laid bare the security vacuum that has taken hold in cities outside Cairo, where police have all but disappeared from the streets. It also exposed how bruised and battered the violence has left Egypt.

For days after vandals ransacked the building Wednesday, there were no police or soldiers in sight as groups of teenage boys burned mummies and broke limestone sculptures too heavy for the thieves to carry away. The security situation remained precarious Monday as gunmen atop nearby buildings fired on a police station near the museum.

Among the stolen antiquities was a statue of the daughter of Pharaoh Akhenaten, who ruled during the 18th dynasty. Archaeologist Monica Hanna described it as a “masterpiece”. Other looted items included gold and bronze Greco-Roman coins, pottery and bronze-detailed sculptures of animals sacred to Thoth, a deity often represented with the head of an ibis or a baboon.

The source is an Associated Press story dated yesterday and published by Auction Central News. “Wednesday,” however, must refer to 8/14 — I think.

This museum “was a testament to the Amarna Period, named after its location in southern Egypt that was once the royal residence of Nefertiti. The area is located on the banks of the Nile River in the province of Minya, some 190 miles (300 kilometers) south of Cairo.”

The article relates some heroics by an archaeologist named Monica Hanna, who under sniper fire, managed — with a guard — to save five sarcoghaghi, two mummies, and other items. But:

The Egypt Heritage Task Force, a group of Egyptian archaeologists who use social media to try to raise awareness about illegal digging for artifacts and looting, said 1,050 pieces were stolen from the museum.

UNESCO also carried a report, accessible here.

The Daily Mail also had a story, along with many pictures, including the one, posted bottom left, here.

The Berlin Decision, Part Two

For those of you who speak German and want more details about the decision to leave Berlin’s Old Master Paintings in the Gemaldegalerie (which I just posted), here are some links, courtesy of RCA reader Wolfgang Gülcker.

Vermeer-BerlinHere are links to:

  • the feasibility study
  • the position paper of the Foundation for Prussian Culture
  • everything related to this decision, including those above and the press release

Gülcker has summarized them in greater detail that I did on my Breaking News post, as follows — verbatim, except where noted:

The results of the feasibility study

The study was conducted by the architects and city planners of the BBR (Bundesamt für Bauwesen and Raumforschung). This federal department was responsible for all new federal buildings in Berlin after 1990 and for all buildings of the Foundation on the Museums Island and the Kulturforum after 1990.

…the 2 main alternatives:

(1) A new building for the old master near the museums island with an integrated presentation of sculptures and paintings and the rebuilding of the Gemäldegalerie for the 20th century.

(2) A new building for the art of the 20th century at the Kulturforum near the Potsdamer Straße, where the Gemäldegalerie is located. Here 3 different possible sites were considered, the 2 main sites are:
(a) between Mies van der Rohes Neue Nationalgalerie and Hans Scharouns Philharmonie at the Potsdamer Straße,
(b) hidden behind the Neue Nationalgalerie opposite of the western wing of the Gemäldegalerie at the Sigismundstraße.

(a) on Google maps: https://maps.google.com/maps?q=52.508061,+13.369036
(b) on Google maps: https://maps.google.com/maps?q=52.507360,+13.365886
(c) on Google maps: https://maps.google.com/maps?q=52.509943,+13.365946

The costs for variant 1 (Museums Island) are estimated to 375 Mio. Euros. If interim solutions for the Gemäldegalerie will be necessary, additional costs up to 40 Mio. Euros will arise. (paper 2, pages 7 and 8)

The costs for variant 2 (a new building for modern art at the Kulturforum) are estimated only to 180 Mio. Euro regardless of location (paper 2 page 8).
The authors emphasize that the Kulturforum is an very important urban site which has been object of city planning for decades. Therefore they demand that all relevant parties of the Foundation and the city take part in an workshop phase before a decision for one of the Kulturforum sites is made (paper 3 page 49).

They evaluate the “visability” of the different Kulturforum sites in the city. They speak of “address building”. The site at the Sigismundstraße (a) is only partially suitable for “address building” (paper 3 page 51), while the site on the Potsdamer Straße (b) is a very prominent address (paper 3 page 53).

And then:

The conclusions of the Foundation (Paper 2 page 10)

1. Their ideal is still alternative 1 [of course] {his comment, not mine}. But that can not be realized financially.

2. The Kulturforum site (a) at the Sigismundstraße is “ideally located” and it is 100 percent public property. (Site b on the Potsdamer Straße is 80 percent public property). The time until realization is estimated to 9 years (10.5 years for site b). (paper 2 page 8)

3. After completion of the study the Foundation has discovered that they only need 10.000 square meters (7.400 square meters exhibition area). The study had to plan with 14.000 square meters (9.200 square meters exhibition area). Therefore they estimate the costs for this variant to only 130 Mio. Euro instead of 180 Mio. (paper 2 page 11).

4. A greater part of the paintings of the Gemäldegalerie shall be presented in the Bodemuseum integrated with the sculptures there (paper 2 page 5). [Today 150 paintings are shown there yet].

Again, thanks to Gülcker, who added his comments, which I will post now in the Comments area.

Photo Credit: Berlin’s Vermeer The Glass of Wine

The Berlin Decision: Old Masters Stay Put

The news I foreshadowed here on Aug. 15 has come true.

Jeffrey Hamburger, the Harvard professor behind the petition, now more than a year-old, asking Prussian authorities to reconsider their plan to mothball half of Berlin’s collection of Old Masters so they could place a modern art collection in the Gemaldegalerie (pictured at right), their current home, is declaring victory.

BerlinGemaldegalerieAnd, true, the Old Master paintings will not move from their current location. The Foundation of Prussian Cultural Heritage has done what one German newspaper called a U-turn, admitting that its original plan, to build a separate museum for the paintings on Museum Island near the Bode Museum, which is home to Old Master sculpture, is too expensive and will not take place. It would have cost 375 million euros.

That is what many of us petitioners feared — that the Old Master put in storage while the new building came into being would last a very long time, possibly indefinitely. Some never wanted the Old Masters to leave the Gemaldegalerie, period, but I was not among them. Nor was I among those who felt any delay in returning them to view — even an indefinite one — was worth it to have the Old Master paintings close to the Old Master sculpture on Museum Island.

So here’s where we are now: In a press release issued about the feasibility study they ordered because of the petition, the Foundation admits that simultaneously placing the modern art in the Gemaldegalerie in the Culture Forum AND relocating the Old Masters to Museum Island is not financially feasible. Therefore, it will now make plans to build a museum for the modern collection at the Culture Forum on Sigismundstraße. It will have 106,500 sq. ft. and cost 130 million euros.

The board of trustees and Parliament must still approve this new plan. The board next meets in December.

Many thanks to a reader in Germany, Wolfgang Gülcker, for sending me the official news.

 

 

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

About Judith H. Dobrzynski

Now an independent journalist, I've worked as a reporter in the culture and business sections of The New York Times, and been the editor of the Sunday business section and deputy business editor there as well as a senior editor of Business Week and the managing editor of CNBC, the cable TV

About Real Clear Arts

This blog is about culture in America as seen through my lens, which is informed and colored by years of reporting not only on the arts and humanities, but also on business, philanthropy, science, government and other subjects. I may break news, but more likely I will comment, provide

Archives