• Home
  • About
    • Engaging Matters
    • Doug Borwick
    • Backstory-Ground Rules
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • Building Communities, Not Audiences
    • Engage Now! A Guide to Making the Arts Indispensable
  • EM’s List
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Engaging Matters

Doug Borwick on vibrant arts and communities

Deadly Sin: I

February 8, 2023 by Doug Borwick

I have written about arrogance before, but in my last post (Cutting Back) I promised to keep my hand in when it seemed important. The topic of arrogance in our industry bears further consideration. As I said in Beware Arrogance, Arrogance, even unconscious arrogance, is a self-inflicted wound that can stop community engagement–the development of relationships with new communities–efforts in their tracks. So, if it is essential to substantially expand our base of support, our attitudes should be examined.

There are (at least) two kinds of arrogance: conscious and unconscious/unexamined. In the world of nonprofit arts there is usually an effort to hide the former. The latter is more widespread and arguably more pernicious. There are also two primary areas of focus for the arrogance: the art we present and the public that is not taking advantage of what we offer.

Conscious arrogance, which is almost never articulated except among “safe” gatherings of arts professionals or aficionados, comes out with respect to both the public and the art. “Art is for everyone” is paid lip service, but there are those (I leave to the reader whether “those” should be read as “some” or “many”) who do not honestly believe that what they present can truly be appreciated by “Bubba” or “Billie Sue.” As for the art, there is a deeply held belief that art of the European Aristocratic Cultural Tradition is superior to all other forms of creative expression.

At the same time, there are those who would be horrified to hear these things spoken and chagrined to believe that such assumptions were hidden away in their foundational beliefs. Yet, without realizing it, they often act upon them when selecting “target audiences” or works to present for “outreach” programs.

Let’s look at some of these assumptions:

Art of the European Aristocratic Cultural Tradition is superior to:

  • All the arts of all other cultures
    Of course, phrasing it that way shows how ludicrous the idea is. “All” is pretty damning in its arrogance. “Most” would not be much better. And if you use “some” then you must realize the need to use “some” with respect to EACT.

    More to the point, for all of its admitted glories EACT art is not “the greatest” in all categories. In music (my area of expertise), while EACT has achieved great things in harmony, counterpoint, and a certain type of large-scale form, it is woefully simplistic in rhythm, improvisation, and “process” forms compared with music from other cultures. I trust this sort of analysis of relative strengths and weaknesses can be applied to cross-cultural comparisons in the other arts. There is much to be learned and valued in art with which we have little familiarity.

    In addition, EACT cultural expression is not uniformly transcendent. There are plenty of works that have justifiably not stood the test of time and some that have (sort of) that might be better left behind. This is true of the body of work in all forms of cultural expression, and those from outside the culture are not in a position to judge which is which.

    EACT art has much to commend it and much to offer. However, it is not the sole pinnacle of human achievement that some might think (consciously or not).
  • All expressions of popular culture
    Again, “all” covers a lot of territory. There are certainly countless examples of works from pop culture that are not, shall we say, “for the ages;” but remember, many of them are not meant to be. Fleeting entertainment is not a sin. However, having acknowledged that, it is not difficult to find examples that do provide catharsis, inspiration, and deep insight into the human condition. As a Beatles fan growing up, I am still stunned by the impact of “Eleanor Rigby” (to cite just one example). And it should be remembered that the careers of both Shakespeare and Dickens had deep roots in appealing to audiences made up of more than just the elites of their day.

This perspective is bad enough. However, even worse is an attitude that (even unconsciously) questions the capacity of the people we need to reach to appreciate our art. That’s where we will begin next time.

Engage!

Doug

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: The Practice of Engagement Tagged With: arrogance, arts, community engagement, relationships

Comments

  1. Jerry Yoshitomi says

    February 10, 2023 at 3:36 pm

    When I first came into the field and I met our leadership, it seemed to me that ‘arrogance’ was a necessary personality trait to succeed in this field and that ‘humility’ was to be avoided.

    Makes me wonder how much arrogance is at the table during ‘peer panel’ reviews?

    • Doug Borwick says

      February 11, 2023 at 4:08 pm

      Excellent question.

About Doug Borwick

Doug Borwick is a past President of the Board of the Association of Arts Administration Educators and was for nearly 30 years Director of the Arts Management and Not-for-Profit Management Programs at Salem College in Winston-Salem, NC. He is CEO of Outfitters4, Inc., providing management services to nonprofit organizations and ArtsEngaged providing training and consultation to artists and arts organization to help them more effectively engage with their communities. [Read More …]

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,533 other subscribers

About Engaging Matters

The arts began as collective activity around the campfire, expressions of community. In a very real sense, the community owned that expression. Over time, with increasing specialization of labor, the arts– especially Western “high arts”– became … [Read More...]

Books

Community Engagement: Why and How

Building Communities, Not Audiences: The Future of the Arts in the United States Engage Now! A Guide to Making the Arts Indispensable[Purchase info below] I have to be honest, I haven’t finished it yet because I’m constantly having to digest the ‘YES’ and ‘AMEN’ moments I get from each … [Read More...]

Gard Foundation Calls for Stories

The Robert E. Gard Foundation is dedicated to fostering healthy communities through arts-based development, it is currently seeking stories from communities in which the arts have improved the lives of citizens in remarkable ways. These stories can either be full descriptions (400-900 words) with photos, video, and web links or mini stories (ca. 200 words) […]

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Alan Harrison on Deadly Sin: II: ““Yes, but it’s Shakespeare!” is a phrase I heard for years in defending the production of the poetry from several…” Feb 17, 19:38
  • Doug Borwick on Deadly Sin: I: “Excellent question.” Feb 11, 16:08
  • Jerry Yoshitomi on Deadly Sin: I: “When I first came into the field and I met our leadership, it seemed to me that ‘arrogance’ was a…” Feb 10, 15:36
  • Doug Borwick on Cutting Back: “Thanks for the kind words. Hope you are well.” Oct 2, 06:58
  • James Undercofler on Cutting Back: “Miss you, Doug! Good heavens, 70! Thank you so very much for what you stand for, and what you have…” Oct 1, 16:28

Tags

arrogance artcentricity artists arts board of directors business model change community community engagement creativity dance diversity education equity evaluation examples excellence funding fundraising future governance gradualism implementation inclusion instrumental international Intrinsic mainstreaming management marketing mission museums music participation partnership programming public good public policy relationships research Robert E. Gard Foundation simplicity structure terminology theatre
Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in