• Home
  • About
    • Engaging Matters
    • Doug Borwick
    • Backstory-Ground Rules
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • Building Communities, Not Audiences
    • Engage Now! A Guide to Making the Arts Indispensable
  • EM’s List
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Engaging Matters

Doug Borwick on vibrant arts and communities

Click

August 7, 2011 by Doug Borwick

There is a thought experiment I give students in a not-for-profit governance class:

A nameless, generic not-for-profit board recognized the need for more diversity in its membership. Aware that they functioned in a community with a large Hispanic/Latino population but had no members from that group, they placed an add in the local H/L paper to recruit someone to the board.

What is wrong with this picture?

When I first began posing the question, it proved to be a real headscratcher. Today, students more readily see that one answer is another question: “Why does no one on the board know anyone from the Hispanic/Latino community?” That realization is a “Click” moment. A light bulb comes on. A new way of thinking about the world is revealed.

The latest issue of Symphony magazine (Summer 2011: available online here) has many articles on the growing awareness of the need for community engagement on the part of  orchestras in the U.S. I highly recommend it. One of my favorite parts of that edition is the point/counterpoint essays from Bruce Coppock and Robert Levine. (Actually, from my point of view, there is very little distance between the two, but that’s a topic for another post.) The pertinent passage here comes from Mr. Levine’s essay, “Change, Sustainability, and First Principles.” Symphony. Summer 2011: 25-31.

A few years ago my orchestra, the Milwaukee Symphony, was on tour in northern Wisconsin shortly after six teenagers were murdered in a mass shooting in the small town of Crandon. We were 50 miles away and we had a night off. Why didn’t it occur to anyone–staff, board, or musicians–that we could have done something remarkable by going to Crandon and playing a memorial concert? But no one thought of it, I doubt that more than a handful of American orchestras, or managers, or board members, or musicians, would have thought of it. (27)

In the words of Debra Barone on a particularly funny episode of Everybody Love Raymond, “And there it is.”

Click.

It often seems that the arts world–or at least portions of it–does not see itself as a member of the community, although it is difficult to document a negative. Here is a textbook demonstration of the point.

And we wonder about the reasons there is limited support for the arts in this country? [See the previous post “Why?“]

Of course this does not mean that the arts world never sees itself “in community” or that it never shares a community’s joys and sorrows. Far from it. Indeed, here is a great counter balance to the example above: http://blog.artsusa.org/2011/08/04/surviving-the-prairie-tsunami/. Hats off to the Minot (ND) Area Council of the Arts. The point is that such a view has not been typical, not expected, not rewarded by some elements of the current arts infrastructure. That is what needs to be addressed. We will do so regularly here.

Engage!

Doug

 

Light switch picture (such as it is) by Doug Borwick.

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Related

Filed Under: Overview, Principles

Comments

  1. MWnyc says

    August 8, 2011 at 9:51 pm

    Robert Levine: “A few years ago my orchestra, the Milwaukee Symphony, was on tour in northern Wisconsin shortly after six teenagers were murdered in a mass shooting in the small town of Crandon. We were 50 miles away and we had a night off. Why didn’t it occur to anyone–staff, board, or musicians–that we could have done something remarkable by going to Crandon and playing a memorial concert?

    Why? I’ll hazard a guess: The musicians’ contract already stipulated working hours and days in detail, including a requirement for days off during tours – and negotiating any exception to the work rules, especially on short notice, would be such a headache that administrators would never think of suggesting it.

    (I have no idea how good or bad union-management relations are the the Milwaukee Symphony, but for an orchestra with tense relations – Philadelphia leaps to mind – an impromptu concert like the one Levine suggests would be even less likely.)

    I’m no union-buster, believe me. But symphony orchestras, by their very size, tend to be too unwieldy for spontaneous schedule changes like that, especially with the work and scheduling rules often written into musicians’ contracts.

    • Doug Borwick says

      August 9, 2011 at 9:40 am

      Don’t lose sight of the real point of using the example. It was not that structural impediments prevented responding to the tragedy. It was that no one thought of doing so. It is about the mindset of entire organizations with respect to their communities. Now, if someone had thought about it, the next thought might well have been that due to labor rules or management priorities it couldn’t be done. That’s a separate issue. Let’s first think about it.

      Click.

About Doug Borwick

Doug Borwick is a past President of the Board of the Association of Arts Administration Educators and was for nearly 30 years Director of the Arts Management and Not-for-Profit Management Programs at Salem College in Winston-Salem, NC. He is CEO of Outfitters4, Inc., providing management services to nonprofit organizations and ArtsEngaged providing training and consultation to artists and arts organization to help them more effectively engage with their communities. [Read More …]

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,552 other subscribers

About Engaging Matters

The arts began as collective activity around the campfire, expressions of community. In a very real sense, the community owned that expression. Over time, with increasing specialization of labor, the arts– especially Western “high arts”– became … [Read More...]

Books

Community Engagement: Why and How

Building Communities, Not Audiences: The Future of the Arts in the United States Engage Now! A Guide to Making the Arts Indispensable[Purchase info below] I have to be honest, I haven’t finished it yet because I’m constantly having to digest the ‘YES’ and ‘AMEN’ moments I get from each … [Read More...]

Gard Foundation Calls for Stories

The Robert E. Gard Foundation is dedicated to fostering healthy communities through arts-based development, it is currently seeking stories from communities in which the arts have improved the lives of citizens in remarkable ways. These stories can either be full descriptions (400-900 words) with photos, video, and web links or mini stories (ca. 200 words) […]

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Jerry Yoshitomi on Deserving Attention: “Doug: Thank you very much for this. I am assuming that much of the local sports coverage is of high…” Mar 25, 16:28
  • Alan Harrison on Deadly Sin: II: ““Yes, but it’s Shakespeare!” is a phrase I heard for years in defending the production of the poetry from several…” Feb 17, 19:38
  • Doug Borwick on Deadly Sin: I: “Excellent question.” Feb 11, 16:08
  • Jerry Yoshitomi on Deadly Sin: I: “When I first came into the field and I met our leadership, it seemed to me that ‘arrogance’ was a…” Feb 10, 15:36
  • Doug Borwick on Cutting Back: “Thanks for the kind words. Hope you are well.” Oct 2, 06:58

Tags

arrogance artcentricity artists arts board of directors business model change community community engagement creativity dance diversity education equity evaluation examples excellence funding fundraising future governance gradualism implementation inclusion instrumental international Intrinsic mainstreaming management marketing mission museums music participation partnership programming public good public policy relationships research Robert E. Gard Foundation simplicity structure terminology theatre
Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in