• Home
  • About
    • Straight Up
    • Jan Herman
    • Contact
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Straight Up | Herman

Arts, Media & Culture News with 'tude

COPYCAT REDUX

April 29, 2006 by Jan Herman

What’s the difference between a plagiarist and a copycat? Nothing really — except one admitted it and the other didn’t, one is a writer and the other is an artist, one had her novel withdrawn by the publisher and the other had his layout in The New York Times Style Magazine defended by a Times editor as a case of copycat “coincidence.”
Consider Kaavya Viswanathan’s plagiarism vs. Vik Muniz’s copycatting.
Here’s a widely cited example, one of many borrowed passages in Viswanathan’s recently published novel “How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life”: “He had too-long shaggy brown hair that fell into his eyes, which were always half shut. His mouth was always curled into a half smile, like he knew about some big joke that was about to be played on you.”
Which bears a striking similarity to this passage in Megan McCafferty’s 2001 novel, “Sloppy Firsts”: “He’s got dusty reddish dreads that a girl could never run her hands through. His eyes are always half-shut. His lips are usually curled in a semi-smile, like he’s in on a big joke that’s being played on you but you don’t know it yet.”
Here’s an example, on the right, of what Muniz produced last December for a NYT Style Magazine fashion spread.


Which bears a striking resemblance to Norman O. Mustill’s image, on the left, from his 1969 book of collages, “Flypaper”:

IMAGE BY MUSTILLIMAGE BY MUNIZ


Although the copied visual image is not exact, it bears as much similarity to Mustill’s original as the plagiarized verbal passage bears to McCafferty’s, and there’s enough exact material — tree branches within a human form in the context of a fashion statement and the referential hand — to draw the appropriate conclusion.
As for the notion that Viswanathan’s plagiarism is of a different order from Muniz’s copycatting if only because of sheer numbers — she apparently copied dozens of passages from two McAfferty novels — it doesn’t hold up unless 1) you fail to see the similarity between Muniz’s borrowed technique of combining newsprint and human figure cutouts in the image on the right with Mustill’s image from his 1971 pamphlet “Twinpak,” on the left, or 2) you fail to compare percentages..

IMAGE BY MUSTILLIMAGE BY MUNIZ


Viswanathan plagiarized roughly 40 passages (a sentence or paragraph each) in a book that comes to 320 pages. As blatant as that is, the total percentage of borrowed words comes to very little compared with the two Muniz copycat images, above, and a less obvious third borrowing (scroll down), which is 50 percent of the six-image Times spread.

Email this to someone
email
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on Reddit
Reddit

Filed Under: main

Jan Herman

When not listening to Bach or Cuban jazz pianist Chucho Valdes, or dancing to salsa, I like to play jazz piano -- but only in the privacy of my own mind.
Another strange fact... Read More…

About

Straight Up

The agenda is just what it says: news of arts, media & culture delivered with attitude. Or as Rock Hudson once said in a movie: "Man is the only … [Read More...]

Books ‘n’ Stuff

I'm the author of several books, including The Z Collection: Portraits & Sketches, just published by Blue Wind Press in a new 2018 edition. My … [Read More...]

My Checkered Career

I've been a staff writer covering arts and culture at the Los Angeles Times, a reporter and movie reviewer at The Daily News in New York, a reporter … [Read More...]

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Jay Jones on Filthy Rotten T.S. Eliot, the Mofo

    I can well imagine that old Limerickologist, Gershon Legman collaborating with Fran Landesman to invent these. Perhaps a clue in...
    Posted Apr 26, 2018
  • william osborne on ‘Peculiar Shortcomings’

    Yes, free moments channel surfing TV in hotel rooms over 9 weeks in 23 cities. Much of the character...
    Posted Apr 23, 2018
  • Jan Herman on ‘Peculiar Shortcomings’

    Thanks for the comment. Once again an amplification that enhances the post. I can’t help thinking that you must have...
    Posted Apr 23, 2018
  • william osborne on ‘Peculiar Shortcomings’

    "At all costs we must get rid of our hypocrisies and falsehoods and see ourselves as we are..." That's...
    Posted Apr 23, 2018
  • william osborne on ‘For Sure Verboten’

    Good to see someone on AJ address this issue. Many implications for the American arts world and its plutocratic...
    Posted Apr 21, 2018
  • Gary Lee-Nova on Speaking for Myself

    A fine poem, Sir!
    Posted Mar 23, 2018
  • Gary Lee-Nova on Once Upon a Time in India . . .

    Astonishing! This publication reminds me of GNAOUA, Number One: 1964. Nice post, Jan! Thank you.
    Posted Mar 23, 2018
  • Gary Lee-Nova on Spike, Smalls, and Mezzrow

    Wow! Just Wow! The presence of the internet outlets/interfaces in relation to the bricks-and-mortar operations is quite astonishing. "Wilner..." Hmmmm......
    Posted Mar 17, 2018
  • Gary Lee-Nova on Poland Dials the Wrong Number

    William, you have posted a set of important questions. And thank you for the mention of "Wir haben es gesehen,"...
    Posted Mar 08, 2018
  • william osborne on Poland Dials the Wrong Number

    It's interesting to put this theme in the context of how the Nazis coerced people in occupied countries to participate...
    Posted Mar 01, 2018

Blogroll

(Latest Wikileaks news in real-time updates.)
Abstract City
AC Institute
All Things Allen Ginsberg
AmericaBlog
American Leftist
Antiwar.com
ArkivMusic.com
Arts & Letters Daily

Bellaart
Blogcritics
Booknotes
Bright Lights Film Journal

C-SPAN
Noam Chomsky
Consortium News
Cost of War
Council on Foreign Relations
Crooks and Liars
Cultural Weekly

The Daily Howler
David E’s Fablog
Dark Roasted Blend
DCReport
Democracy Now!
Devil Ducky

Ehrensteinland
Tim Ellis: Comedy
Eschaton

Film Threat
Robert Fisk
Flixnosh (David Elliott’s movie menu)
Fluxlist Europe

Good Reads
The Guardian (London)
GUERNICA: A Magazine of Art & Politics

Herman (Literary) Archive, Northwestern Univ. Library
The Huffington Post

Inter Press Service News Agency
The Intercept
Internet Movie Database (IMDb)
Doug Ireland
IT: International Times, The Newspaper of Resistance

Jacketmagazine
Clive James

Henry Kisor
Paul Krugman

Lannan Foundation
Life During Wartime
Los Angeles Times

Metacritic
Mimeo Mimeo
Moloko Plus

Nat. Arts Journalism Program
National Security Archive
The New York Times
NO!art

Open City
Osborne & Conant

The Overgrown Path

Political Irony
Poynter

The Quarterly Conversation

Rain Taxi
The Raw Story
RealityStudio.org
Bill Reed
The Reeler
Rhizome
Rwanda Project

Salon
Seeing Black
Senses of Cinema
Seven Stories Press
Slate
Studs Terkel
The Synergic Theater

TalkLeft
The 3rd Page
ThugLit: Writing About Wrongs
Times Square Cam
The Tin Man
t r u t h o u t

Ubu Web

Vox

The Wall Street Journal
Wikigate
Wikipedia
The Washington Post
James Wolcott
World Catalogue
World Newspapers, Magazines & News Sites

Email this to someone
email
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on Reddit
Reddit
This blog published under a Creative Commons license

an ArtsJournal blog

Copyright © 2018 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in