• Home
  • About
    • Straight Up
    • Jan Herman
    • Contact
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

Straight Up | Jan Herman

Arts, Media & Culture News with 'tude

KEEPING SCORE

October 26, 2003 by cmackie

Charles Murray is stirring up trouble again. Emily Eakin reports in “A Cultural Scorecard Says West Is Ahead” that
he says it’s not his intention. “But his record is hard to ignore.”


Murray, the conservative co-author of “The Bell Curve,”
which put the civilized world in an uproar when it professed that whites were
smarter than blacks due to differences in hereditary IQ, now claims in another wicked
book, “Human Accomplishment: The Pursuit of Excellence in the Arts and Sciences,
800 B.C. to 1950,”
that:


1) “Europeans and North Americans account for 97 percent of scientific accomplishment,”
Eakin notes, based on his inventory of “eight fields — astronomy, biology, chemistry, earth
sciences, physics, mathematics, medicine and technology — as well as a combined index ranking
scientists from all disciplines.”


2) While Europe has been the overwhelmingly dominant influence on human achievement —
as measured by the relative amount of space given in 34 standard reference works in four
languages to 4,002 significant people in the arts and sciences — the European heyday of great
accomplishment is over.


3) The most influential scientist ever is Newton, followed by Galileo and Aristotle. Then in a
steep drop come Kepler, Lavoisier, Descartes, Huygens and Laplace, followed by Einstein (ninth
on the list), Faraday, Pasteur and Ptolemy. Darwin doesn’t show up until 17th, after Hooke,
Leibniz, Rutherford and Euler. Finally, Berzelius, Euclid and Maxwell round out the top 20.


“For literature, philosophy and visual art,” Eakin writes, “Murray decided that unbaised global
inventories were not feasible: the references works were too skewed toward their national
traditions. So he created separate indexes by culture instead.”

But if you think the
scientific list is peculiar, perhaps not so much in makeup as in sequence, the list for the giants of
Western literature will amaze you. Shakespeare comes out first, no surprise. But Goethe ranks
second, ahead of Dante (third), Virgil (fourth) and Homer (fifth). There is no Cervantes, no Saint
Augustine and no Saint Thomas Aquinas, to whose humanist influence on Christianity Murray
himself attributes Western dominance.


Any listing like this is bound to be questioned. But when it lays claim to qualitative accuracy
based on a statistical method open to doubt — Eakins quotes several historians and scholars on its
biases and value judgments — it seems a fool’s errand.


Murray’s top 20 literary giants include Petrarch, but no Plato or Lucretius; Euripedes, but no
Aeschylus or Sophocles and no Aristophanes; Byron, but no Wordsworth or Keats, and no
Chaucer or Milton; it includes Rousseau, Voltaire, Moliere, Racine and Victor Hugo, but not
Montaigne, Balzac, Baudelaire, Stendahl, Flaubert or Proust; Sir Walter Scott but not Jonathan
Swift or Jane Austen; Virgil and Horace but not Ovid.


Schiller makes the list but not Freud or Thomas Mann; Boccaccio make the list along with
Tolstoy and Dostoevsky; but there’s no Pushkin; Ibsen makes the list but not Chekov; there’s no
Kierkegaard or Nietzsche, Orwell or Joyce, Twain or Faulkner. And what of Yeats or Blake? Not
there.

Share on email
Email
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on reddit
Reddit

Filed Under: main

Jan Herman

When not listening to Bach or Cuban jazz pianist Chucho Valdes, or dancing to salsa, I like to play jazz piano -- but only in the privacy of my own mind.
Another strange fact... Read More…

About

My Books

Several books of poems have been published in recent years by Moloko Print, Statdlichter Presse, Phantom Outlaw Editions, and Cold Turkey … [Read More...]

Straight Up

The agenda is just what it says: news of arts, media & culture delivered with attitude. Or as Rock Hudson once said in a movie: "Man is the only … [Read More...]

Contact me

We're cutting down on spam. Please fill in this form. … [Read More...]

Archives

Blogroll

Abstract City
AC Institute
ACKER AWARDS New York
All Things Allen Ginsberg
Antiwar.com
arkivmusic.com
Artbook&
Arts & Letters Daily

Befunky
Bellaart
Blogcritics
Booknotes
Bright Lights Film Journal

C-SPAN
Noam Chomsky
Consortium News
Cost of War
Council on Foreign Relations
Crooks and Liars
Cultural Daily

The Daily Howler
Dark Roasted Blend
DCReport
Deep L
Democracy Now!

Tim Ellis: Comedy
Eschaton

Film Threat
Robert Fisk
Flixnosh (David Elliott’s movie menu)
Fluxlist Europe

Good Reads
The Guardian
GUERNICA: A Magazine of Art & Politics

Herman (Literary) Archive, Northwestern Univ. Library
The Huffington Post

Inter Press Service News Agency
The Intercept
Internet Archive (WayBackMachine)
Internet Movie Database (IMDb)
Doug Ireland
IT: International Times, The Magazine of Resistance

Jacketmagazine
Clive James

Kanopy (stream free movies, via participating library or university)
Henry Kisor
Paul Krugman

Lannan Foundation
Los Angeles Times

Metacritic
Mimeo Mimeo
Moloko Print
Movie Geeks United (MGU)
MGU: The Kubrick Series

National Security Archive
The New York Times
NO!art

Osborne & Conant
The Overgrown Path

Poets House
Political Irony
Poynter

Quanta Magazine

Rain Taxi
The Raw Story
RealityStudio.org
Bill Reed
Rhizome
Rwanda Project

Salon
Senses of Cinema
Seven Stories Press
Slate
Stadtlichter Presse
Studs Terkel
The Synergic Theater

Talking Points Memo (TPM)
TalkLeft
The 3rd Page
Third Mind Books
Times Square Cam
The Tin Man
t r u t h o u t

Ubu Web

Vox

The Wall Street Journal
Wikigate
Wikipedia
The Washington Post
The Wayback Machine (Internet Archive)
World Catalogue
World Newspapers, Magazines & News Sites

The XD Agency

Share on email
Email
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on reddit
Reddit
This blog published under a Creative Commons license

an ArtsJournal blog

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in