The Seattle Times reports "With millennial philanthropy money flowing, arts groups miss out": [Elizabeth] Van Nostrand explained that Effective Altruism “is extremely quantitative. ‘How much money does it take them to save a life? Give to the one that saves the most.’ ” Though millennials like Van Nostrand and Salvatier are a generosity-minded bunch, this data-driven approach has left a traditional beneficiary of charitable giving out in the cold: the arts. Cultural institutions, which have historically been high on the list of those … [Read more...]
Performing arts and cities and (again) the creative class
A new study just published in the academic journal Economic Development Quarterly looks at the links between big (budget over $2 million) performing arts organizations and the change in the proportion of the metro workforce that is in Richard Florida's definition of the 'creative class'. The article, by Arthur Nelson and colleagues is (behind a paywall) here, and Florida discusses here. Artsjournal.com links to it with the clickbait "The study finds substantial evidence that performing arts organizations add to both the growth of the knowledge … [Read more...]
The creative class won’t save your arts organizations
Let's talk about Hartford. I've never been to Connecticut, but in the past week I have read two stories about Hartford, and it is interesting to think about the links, if any. First, the symphony is in financial troubles. Dan Haar of the Hartford Courant reports, "The symphony is bleeding $1.3 million a year and nearing the end of its cash reserves." Hartford's Connecticut Opera went bust in 2009. So far, a familiar story to a number of mid-sized US cities and their 'legacy' arts organizations. The other story comes from Richard Florida's … [Read more...]
About that University of Kentucky mural
At the University of Kentucky a 1930's WPA-funded mural by Ann Rice O'Hanlon has been temporarily covered while the university administration, faculty and students deliberate on the presentation of the work and its depiction of African-Americans. The story has prompted a response from author Wendell Berry, in an opinion piece in the Lexington Herald-Leader, where he writes: Though I willingly would do so if it were possible, I cannot understand the University of Kentucky’s decision to hide Ann Rice O’Hanlon’s fresco in Memorial Hall. The … [Read more...]
Does the creative class matter for regional growth?
In a recent post, Richard Florida looks at the growth in the 'creative class' in US metro areas since the year 2000. The biggest increase is in what was, in 2000, a city not known for creative class workers, Las Vegas. Indianapolis, Portland, Salt Lake City, and Cincinnati also post large (above 20%) gains in number of creative class workers. Does it matter? Here are a few questions that come to mind. First, I think a reasonable goal for cities is to attain broadly distributed gains across its population in standard of living and quality … [Read more...]
Blog sabbatical
Every once and a while I need to take a break from blogging, and as our semester comes to a close I know this is one of those times, to attend to other duties, to read the long list of books in my queue, and to stand back to try for something of a wider view of where arts management and policy are headed. I can sense when I am starting to repeat myself, at which point it is time to hit the refresh button. Thanks to all readers, and to Artsjournal for being such an invaluable site for news and opinion. À la prochaine ... … [Read more...]
Big data and price discrimination: chill
A search on our blog host artsjournal.com re 'big data' yields a lot of hits, suggesting it is obviously something about which arts managers need to be aware of, and which citizens might have cause to fear as corporations and governments use data in hidden but nefarious ways. But is it really all that? A recent post from the Brookings Institution on big data and price discrimination highlights for me some of the unwarranted fears and speculations. The post gives three examples of potential problems. First: Companies could use Big Data to … [Read more...]
Are nonprofit arts organizations special?
April 16, 2015 marked the opening session of a conference held at the School of Public and Environmental Affairs at Indiana University Bloomington, on Advancing the Field(s) of Nonprofit Management: New Structures, New Solutions. I was asked to speak about the arts, specifically about relationships between nonprofit arts organizations and the commercial and public sectors. Our session chair, my SPEA colleague Beth Gazley, asked us to say something ‘provocative’ in our allotted few minutes. So, for what it’s worth… Artists, and nonprofit arts … [Read more...]
A note on key performance indicators
My son goes to a wonderful elementary school - all his teachers have been terrific. His county school board produces the worst report cards ever (so far). The report cards are 'growth-based', meant to measure progress from competency levels exhibited at the beginning of the school year. Fair enough. But there are 40 'essential learnings' in language, and 26 in math. And the parent has no guide as to which of these 'essential learnings' have been emphasized in class, or as to which are most important for general progress. My older children … [Read more...]
Dynamic pricing and market segmentation at the theatre (and the hospital)
This post is about theatre pricing, from a unlikely source. Today's New York Times has a piece by Austin Frakt on hospital pricing, and whether and how changes in funding of patients through public sector programs might change hospital charges to privately insured patients. Mid-way through, the article looks for an analogy from the arts: The theory that hospitals charge private insurers more because public programs pay less is known as cost shifting. What underlies this theory is that a hospital’s costs — those for staff, equipment, supplies, … [Read more...]