Jack Tracy’s story about Jake Hanna’s reflexive quip the night he learned of John Lennon’s murder inspired an assortment of responses from readers of the Jazz West Coast listserve. Here is one exchange, courtesy of the JWC list:
From: Jeff Jansen
Subject: John Lennon Anecdote
Is this what jazz people consider humor: celebrating the murder of one
musician and wishing for the murders of three more? Oh, yeah I forgot the
jazz credo: if it’s not jazz, it’s not music; and if you don’t play jazz
you’re not really a musician. I guess we can now add: if you’re any other
kind of musician, you deserve to die soon.
Jake Hanna is a bastard for making the joke, and Jack Tracy is a bastard for
loving Jake for saying it, but neither deserves to die before his time.
Jeff Jansen | Portland, Oregon | USA
From: joseph lang
Subject: RE: John Lennon Anecdote
Jeff,
I do not know your age, but I have seen several comments about the Jake
Hanna anecdote off-list that lead me to conclude that the reaction to Jake’s
comments might to be generational. I do not believe that Jake, or anyone,
welcomed Lennon’s death in any real sense. He was just smugly reacting to
the effect that the advent of the Beatles had on musical tastes, and the
concomitant effect that it had on the music business, especially for jazz
players. The Beatles, and rock music in general, certainly did not help
jazz musicians, except for those who benefitted from studio gigs on rock
recordings. I can understand how one could be offended by reading Jake’s
comment in the abstract, but, given the kind of humor that is often a part
of the jazz culture, Jake’s comment does not seem any more insensitive than
a lot of other comments by jazzmen that have been passed along through the
years. To those who put Lennon on a pedistal as some kind of super cultural
icon, a judgement that I do not share, I guess that they could never
understand the whimsy of Jake’s comment. I personally considered many of
Lennon’s positions, particularly his rather public acknowledgement of his
involvement in the drug culture, to be as offensive to me as Jake’s comment
is to you. I guess that it is all a matter of perspective.
Joe Lang
For information about subscribing to the Jazz West Coast list, click here.