Bill Kirchner took time out of his busy schedule to send a response to a review.
Thanks for commenting on jazz audiences’ “self-conscious rote clapping” after every solo. This to me is the most mindless of all jazz customs. (Where did this idiocy come from–does anyone know?) It usually prevents audiences from hearing the beginning of each solo–and hearing the opening phrases is often the key to understanding an improviser’s intent.
I once read a “jazz for kids” booklet that told them to clap for each solo, lest the performers be insulted. God help us!







Recent Comments
Doug Ramsey on Weekend Listening Tips (Bi-Coastal)
Amazon seems to be offering to serve as a middleman to provide Stridemonster! as an MP3 download for nine bucks or a CD for $80.00.Ted O'Reilly on Weekend Listening Tips (Bi-Coastal)
Please pass on to Bill Kirchner my thanks in highlighting the Stridemonster! album I produced. I was at the Bern concert and spoke...David on Weekend Listening Tips (Bi-Coastal)
Ken, I have that LP - make me an offer. The four pianists were seated back to back, apparently with only one mic on each...Doug Ramsey on Weekend Listening Tips (Bi-Coastal)
I'm afraid that it went the way of most of my other LPs before the last big move.Ken Dryden on Weekend Listening Tips (Bi-Coastal)
I've long been a collector of duo piano recordings, especially after hearing so many fun combinations on Marian McPartland's Piano Jazz. But do you have...