• Home
  • About
    • What’s going on here
    • Kyle Gann
    • Contact
  • AJBlogs
  • ArtsJournal

PostClassic

Kyle Gann on music after the fact

The End of Exceptionalism

September 9, 2010 by Kyle Gann

ClassicalForm.jpgIn my pedantically wonkish way, I’m excited to be teaching my sonata-form classes with William E. Caplin’s book Classical Form (Oxford, 1998), as I have been for several years now. For those who don’t know it, Caplin went through the complete sonata-form works of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven, and catalogued everything that happens in all of them – what theme the development starts with, what relative keys get referred to in the codas, and like that. I don’t use the book as a textbook: even though Caplin’s writing style is admirably clear, it’s too dense and dependent on hundreds of examples, and to tell the truth, I’ve never yet gotten through the whole thing myself. Read four paragraphs and your eyes glaze over from the amount of detailed information you’re trying to take in. (I once talked to someone at Oxford about how useful an undergrad-friendly version of the book would be, and she told me one was being contemplated.) But I’ve outlined chapters for my students as a kind of flowchart for what’s possible in sonata form, and it’s made it feasible to teach the subject honestly. I think when I was in school I was given some kind of “typical” sonata form chart (if indeed we ever paid any attention to any music before Webern, which I don’t specifically recall doing), from which, of course, every sonata we ever looked at – deviated. But Caplin offers a descriptive plan rather than a prescriptive one. So yesterday in class we went through the outline, and then through movement 1 of Beethoven’s Op. 2 No. 3 – and every move Beethoven made was one of the possibilities in the Caplin-based flow chart. One student, who had apparently gotten a whiff of the old prescriptive-style training, asked, “Can we look at a typical sonata first, one that follows all the rules?” And I said, “There’s no such thing as a typical sonata. Might as well ask me to go out on the street and bring in a typical person.” Instead of having to explain why every piece we listen to is an exception to most of the rules, I can teach the whole conception of sonata form as a range of possibilities and, better yet, meanings, some of which get chosen for identifiable logical or expressive reasons. It’s nice to have one theoretical subject I can teach without making excuses for the lameness of the pedagogy. (Sometimes we look at Clementi, Dussek, and Hummel, too, and find some possibilities outside Caplin’s range.)

I’ve told the wonderful story before about my late friend Jonathan Kramer who said to a class, “You’ve all probably been taught the fiction that there are three kinds of minor scale.” Student: “If that’s the fiction, what’s the reality?” Jonathan: “There is no reality.” But in sonata class, there’s now a reality.

Share:

  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: main

Comments

  1. Dan Schmidt says

    September 9, 2010 at 12:27 pm

    This sounds great; thanks for the pointer.
    It sounds a bit similar in some ways to Schoenberg’s Fundamentals of Musical Composition (which appears to be out of print, sadly), which is a wonderful catalog/cookbook for classical composition, always the book I pull out for inspiration if I’m having trouble with form.

  2. Patrick says

    September 10, 2010 at 12:48 am

    “Caplin specializes primarily in the theory of musical form. His extensive investigations into formal procedures of late-eighteenth-century music culminated in the 1998 book Classical Form: A Theory of Formal Functions for the Instrumental Music of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven (Oxford University Press), which won the 1999 Wallace Berry Book Award from the Society for Music Theory. A textbook version of this work, Analyzing Classical Form, is in preparation and is due to be published early in 2012.”
    Would that be the book being contemplated? It was used in a class I took in my undergrad as well. I think it is the closest any of my textbooks has ever come to being Canadian.
    KG replies: Must be it. You know more than I.

  3. Eric Grunin says

    September 10, 2010 at 12:56 pm

    Sounds like my kind of book–insisting on looking at the complete corpus, not just the “interesting” cases (which are by definition atypical). Going to order this right now!

  4. Daniel Villegas says

    September 11, 2010 at 11:58 am

    Could you post the flowchart for us students around the world? A descriptive plan is definitely the best approach to learning sonata form, and well, flowcharts are cool.
    By the way, I love the book on 4’33, thank you so much.
    KG replies: Thanks for the latter. I’d feel uncomfortable putting up my outline; Mr. Caplin might think I had misrepresented something, and in class I can explain each point, refer to the book, and quote it if necessary. I’m not a scholar on sonata form, and shouldn’t be consulted as one.

  5. mclaren says

    September 12, 2010 at 2:26 am

    This is why biology offers a better model for music than physics or mathematics. Every species exhibits a wide range of variations, and there is no such thing as a “typical” type of insect or a “typical” fish. Some fish crawl up on land and breathe air for short periods of time (lungfish), while some types of insects exist in two distinct forms, one of which can’t eat and the other of which can’t reproduce (caterpillars and butterflies).
    In physics, every electron is exactly the same and there is such a thing as an ideal gas. But there’s no such thing as an “ideal sonata” in music. The faster we can purge music of physics envy, the better.

Kyle Gann

Just as Harry Partch called himself a "philosophic music man seduced into carpentry," I'm a composer seduced into musicology... Read More…

What’s going on here

So classical music is dead, they say. Well, well. This blog will set out to consider that dubious factoid with equanimity, if not downright enthusiasm [More]

Kyle Gann's Home Page More than you ever wanted to know about me at www.kylegann.com

PostClassic Radio The radio station that goes with the blog, all postclassical music, all the time; see the playlist at kylegann.com.

Recent archives for this blog

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Michael Robinson on Another Do-It-Yourselfer: “Your compositional palette intrigues me, the number 33 being multiplicative of my birthday, March 11. Perusing your scores, I also…” Sep 3, 17:29
  • Peter Thoegersen on Another Do-It-Yourselfer: “You do realize I love your pieces here, and theyre not for YOU theyre for US. Man.…” Sep 2, 16:33
  • mclaren on Another Do-It-Yourselfer: “I used to think you were a good composer who sometimes produced a great piece. Now I think you're a…” Aug 28, 23:41
  • Henry Gwiazda on Another Do-It-Yourselfer: “Hey Kyle, Just finished listening to Orbital Resonance. I'm very enthusiastic about it. It really sounds like…” Aug 24, 16:48
  • Lyle Sanford on An Analytical Cornucopia, Wanted or Not: “Thanks so much for doing this. A few months back I read your American Music in the 20th Century and…” May 28, 08:52

Sites to See

American Mavericks - the Minnesota Public radio program about American music (scripted by Kyle Gann with Tom Voegeli)

Kalvos & Damian's New Music Bazaar - a cornucopia of music, interviews, information by, with, and on hundreds of intriguing composers who are not the Usual Suspects

Iridian Radio - an intelligently mellow new-music station

New Music Box - the premiere site for keeping up with what American composers are doing and thinking

The Rest Is Noise - The fine blog of critic Alex Ross

William Duckworth's Cathedral - the first interactive web composition and home page of a great postminimalist composer

Mikel Rouse's Home Page - the greatest opera composer of my generation

Eve Beglarian's Home Page- great Downtown composer

David Doty's Just Intonation site

Erling Wold's Web Site - a fine San Francisco composer of deceptively simple-seeming music, and a model web site

The Dane Rudhyar Archive - the complete site for the music, poetry, painting, and ideas of a greatly underrated composer who became America's greatest astrologer

Utopian Turtletop, John Shaw's thoughtful blog about new music and other issues

Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2018 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.