Tidbits

Yeah, I was underwhelmed by the 'Modern” offerings on the reborn IMSLP---essentially all of the “finds” I managed to view previously are no longer available for download, most likely because of their previous dispute with UE. As far as I can tell, they're in the process of working these IP things through, but it's pretty lame right now. I did post two recent works, though, and hopefully others will get their stuff up as well, so there's reason to be optimistic.

Kyle,

I don't think that size overshadows anything. Whenever it has happened, I have been honored to have my words appear in print alongside yours! I thought it was actually strangely apt that pieces on Singleton and Wuorinen appear side-by-side since I learned earlier this year when I spoke to Alvin for NewMusicBox that he actually studied with CW and had some nice things to say about the experience.

FJO

P.S.: And for the record, as far as making enemies goes, if a book publisher ever gave me the opportunity to write a history of American music, I would include both of you ;)

KG replies: Thanks, Frank. I want to be clear that openmindedness (which I know you like to take to olympic extremes) has, in my mind, nothing to do with it. I love a lot of music as complex and intricate as Wuorinen's, but I just don't think his is very good. His career has been widely ratified by lots of awards and honors that he actively sought, and I have never felt that it was my obligation as a musicologist, or historian, or a human being, to endorse the bad decisions of music organizations that give awards to composers with little regard for the actual quality of their music. An awful lot of people in the music world consider Wuorinen an incongruously visible minor composer, and I am among them. Who knows what motivates Singleton (an infinitely better composer) to speak well of him as a teacher?

If some demiurge appeared to me and offered to bestow upon me a talent for not making enemies, I'd think long and hard before accepting. But you're lucky you were born with it.

Always learn something from your articles. Haven't heard the word "imagist" used in association with (modern) music before. I'm familiar with imagism as a literary movement, specifically as an early 20th-century successor to French symbolism...but not in modern music. In fact, the only reference I could find to imagism in music involves the sadly deceptive use of the term "music" to describe onomotapoeia in poetry.

Is imagism in modern music a well-recognized category, like primitivism or serialism?

KG replies: I don't think it's well recognized, but I've made an ongoing case for it over the years, to distnguish music that is low in syntactical connections and high in the repetition of recurring sound complexes.