• Subscribe
    • Free AJ Newsletters
    • Subscribe to AJ’s Premium Newsletters
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Tumblr
    • RSS
  • Advertising
    • Advertising
    • About AJClassifieds
    • Place a Classified Ad
  • About
    • About
    • Contact
    • Sources

ArtsJournal

  • HOME
  • DANCE
  • IDEAS
  • ISSUES
  • MEDIA
  • MUSIC
  • PEOPLE
  • THEATRE
  • VISUAL
  • WORDS
  • AUDIENCE
  • AJBLOGS

A Museum Culture of Symphony Orchestras?

leadership Posted: February 15, 2017 2:51 pm

By David Gier

Having worked with Joe Horowitz and having read his books I agree in principal with his assessment of the “classical” music industry, its history and present situation. Copland’s quote from 1941 stands as well today as it did 76 years ago. My copy of Joe’s “Classical Music in America” is dog-eared, with quotes from people during the late 19th-century underlined which could have come from my subscribers today. We have indeed created a museum culture out of this art form, one which is perceived as irrelevant for many reasons, an unnecessary result of a focus on the “masterpieces” we all know and love at the expense of the creation of our own voice.

The issue of a cultural shift in America (some would say decline) and the diminishing of the importance of education in music and the arts specifically, in the humanities more generally, is in my mind at least as important a factor. The inundation of our lives with popular culture and multiple distractions, and the lack of distinction of fine art from more popular forms confuses the issue further as people view everything through the same lens. (This is most prominent in American culture; in much of Europe and even Mexico, Central and South America this is not so much the case.) Our industry muddies the waters still more by marketing what we play in the same manner as more popular musical forms. I personally think of this as false advertising; we do not need to apologize for what we play – art and entertainment serve different functions in society. As Joe has often suggested, we need to reframe our institutions as cultural resources; I would say for the understanding of our own society and its place within history.

I have always believed that our art form is living and breathing, and have devoted myself, as well as substantial time and resources of the SDSO, to supporting living American composers. That is not to say that I am a lover of contemporary music, rather that I am a believer. I believe in the power of art to influence, even restore, society and I idealistically hope for a cultural renaissance in which art can serve in this way. (I often say: if you want to be a game-changer you have to stay in the game; you can’t simply sit on the sidelines and complain.) Particularly at this time in our nation (and in the “western” world) the role of the arts is very important, and could/should/would be more relevant than at any period in recent memory.

There is not much music I don’t love, particularly once I’m involved in the making of it, so carrying the banner of new music, helping in whatever way I can to engender our American school of composition (even at this late stage) is no burden. I began at the SDSO with a series based on the Pulitzer Prize, using it as a recognizable imprimatur to validate a new music director’s programming choices; it worked as a way to introduce new music to an audience which had heard very little of it.


David Gier is the music director of the South Dakota Symphony

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

leadership

Read the story in

  • The Complete Poems: 1965-2020 Michael Butterworth’s Radical Legacy in Verse
    For more than half a century the dissident British author, editor, and underground publisher Michael Butterworth has been "a quiet unobtrusive voice in poetry, with roots both in the small press poetry... Read more
    AJBlog: Straight|Up Published on: 2023-01-28
  • “Fashion Victim” (Part II): “Lagerfeld” Subverts the Met
    My May 2005 NY Times Op-Ed page commentary—Fashion Victim—now has a CultureGrrl sequel, thanks to the Met’s announcement of its upcoming Costume Institute show—“Karl Lagerfeld: A Line of Beauty” (May 5–July 16).... Read more
    AJBlog: CultureGrrl Published on: 2023-01-28
  • Christopher Sierra talks about culturally-responsive teaching
    Christopher Sierra , Voice & Master of Music in Music Education Faculty at Longy School of Music, talks about culturally responsive teaching in the arts.... Read more
    AJBlog: Aaron Dworkin Published on: 2023-01-28
  • A Copy Editor Disavows Copyediting
    It’s clear that copyediting as it’s typically practiced is a white supremacist project, that is, not only for the particular linguistic forms it favors and upholds, which belong to the cultures of... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • Black Dancers In Pacific Northwest Ballet Reflect On Their Careers
    When you see more people who look like you onstage, it makes you want to go and it makes you want to bring people with you. If there are people who look... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • Naps Are A Creative Canvas
    The relationship between sleep, dreaming, and creativity has been the subject of conjecture for hundreds of years. Reports of creative inspiration and discoveries made by artists, inventors, and scientists while dreaming suggest... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • Tales From The Road: The Book-signings/readings No One Comes To
    In-person author appearances are back in local bookstores, after a long pandemic absence. And for every standing-room-only reading featuring a massively well-known name, there might be a quiet event, with empty chairs... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • No, We Don’t Have Different Learning Styles
    Despite its appeal, there is simply no credible evidence to support the idea that attending to learning styles actually supports learning, regardless of how well-intentioned the teacher might be. To paraphrase the... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • It Isn’t Just Humanities: Science Education Is Seriously Broken
    Leaders see science as essential to national prosperity, well-being and, of course, competitiveness. So, is research fit for the challenge of advancing, refining or critiquing these goals? Not exactly. And it won’t... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • Popular Music Has Become An Asset Class
    Justin Bieber selling his catalogue for $200 million is just the latest example.  Investment funds have been paying big money for rights to pop songs and jazz, especially older music, and collecting... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • The Dancers Who Escaped Russia
    If the war has made refugees out of some Ukrainian dancers, it’s made soldiers out of others. – 60 Minutes... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • “Opera Can Be Hip-Hop, and Hip-Hop Can Be Opera”: Figaro In A South Side Chicago Barbershop
    Baritone Will Livermore and DJ King Rico have adapted Rossini’s Barber of Seville into a work called The Factotum, “blending operatic writing with a kaleidoscope of styles like R&B, funk, hip-hop, gospel,... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • On a Strategy of Indeterminacy: Or, the Value of Creating Pathways to the Unforeseen
    Given widespread recognition of the need to find radically new and beautiful alternatives to many of the ways of being, doing, and knowing that we embraced throughout the 20th century—new ways of... Read more
    AJBlog: Jumper Published on: 2023-01-27
  • Intriguing Questions About How AI Trains On Large Language Models
    Do they merely memorize training data and reread it out loud, or are they picking up the rules of English grammar and the syntax of C language? Are they building something like... Read more
    AJBlog: Seeing Things Published on: 2023-01-27
  • ‘Shall we be lighthearted . . .’
    'Or shall we / bite our elbows / to the bone?'... Read more
    AJBlog: Straight|Up Published on: 2023-01-26
  • Novelist Kevin Wilson tackles serious issues through an outrageous premise
    Kevin Wilson, the author of the NEA Big Read title Nothing to See Here, explains his long-time obsession with spontaneous human combustion—a condition that figures prominently in the novel. In a nutshell, 28-year-old Lillian is... Read more
    AJBlog: Measure for Measure Published on: 2023-01-26
  • “Supermusician” Roscoe Mitchell’s paintings
    Roscoe Mitchell — internationally renown composer, improviser, ensemble leader, winds and reeds virtuoso who has pioneered the use of “little instruments” and dramatic shifts of sonic scale in the course of becoming... Read more
    AJBlog: Jazz Beyond Jazz Published on: 2023-01-25
  • A Great One Died 11 Years Ago Today
    And there he was in a dream. We are in some restaurant, a San Francisco dream. He gives me a manuscript to read on elegant Mary Beach / Claude Pélieu stationery with raised... Read more
    AJBlog: Straight|Up Published on: 2023-01-24
  • Are We Past Those Pandemic Ghosts?
    A pub directly across the street from the main branch of the New York Public Library has replaced the pub that was shuttered there during the pandemic. Doorway artwork now invites the... Read more
    AJBlog: Straight|Up Published on: 2023-01-22
  • Miriam Goldberg Owens talks about the practice of “radical excellence”
    Miriam Goldberg Owens, President and CEO of The People’s Music School, talks about the practice of “radical excellence” and illustrates the impact of music education.... Read more
    AJBlog: Aaron Dworkin Published on: 2023-01-21
.