an blog | AJBlog Central | Contact me | Advertise | Follow me:

New York Times dissents from British critics

Steve Smith, new music specialist on the New York Times, has given ENO’s Sunken Garden a warm reception, in contrast to the collective view of the local newspaper critics. Steve finds Michel van der Aa’s opera in some respects ‘positively old-fashioned’ and he rightly acknowledges that it divides opinion: Whether “Sunken Garden” represents a brave new world for an art form sometimes derided — wrongly — as antiquated and irrelevant is debatable.

His conclusion, however, is positive: Still, verisimilitude is not high among the qualities we generally demand of opera. “Sunken Garden,” despite its contorted revelations and desultory conclusion, is unquestionably a bold, rewarding venture that demands consideration.

Read the full review here. This debate will run and run, as will the opera itself.

sg1

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

an ArtsJournal blog