Anybody notice that today is the 200th anniversary of the first performance of Beethoven's fifth symphony? It was 22 December 1808 at the Theater an der Wien, if Thayer is not mistaken. The orchestra played badly, the hall was cold and audience tolerance was exhausted by an overlong programme. But this was the night that the symphony shed its courtly deference and became a universal art form - a work that represented fate and the individual, and indicating that a free … [Read more...]
All’s quiet at the NY Philharmonic
Since last week's sordid events, there have been three developments: - The Philharmonic's chief executive is apparently unwell. - The critic who praised Gilbert Kaplan's performance of Mahler's second symphony has admitted he did not acknowledge the conductor's full authority in his review. - And two more players have reiterated the trombonist's attack on the guest conductor in language so similar to one another as to suggest a football huddle. On the first … [Read more...]
The player who forgot his place
- Hold the front page, hot story coming in. - What is it? - There's a player in the orchestra who didn't like last week's conductor. - Come again? Yeah, that's right. There's a trombone in the New York Phil beefing on his blog about the guy who did Mahler 2. Get some pictures in. Is this some kind of mistimed joke, or the end of journalism on the New York Times? For reasons better left uninvestigated, the Times has made a C1 splash today of comments made by a trombonist - the third trombone, I … [Read more...]
The Record Doctor’s surgery is open now
This coming Monday, Dec 8, I'm doing a half-hour slot on WNYC at 2-2.30 pm, called The Record Doctor. The idea, linked to my book The Life and Death of Classical Music, is that people can email or ring in to ask me to prescribe a record remedy for their particular lifestyle dilemma - dinner with the boss's new post-modern wife, a second date with a Nigel Kennedy fan, a ceasefire negotiation with Condoleeza Rice - or just a deep-seated need for a piece of music to cope with … [Read more...]
Does Ma’am love Brahms?
Checking out the Condoleeza Rice Brahms recital clip at Buckingham Palace, one had to cast the mind back an awful long time to fathom when a serving officer of the US government last performed a piece of music before a reigning British monarch. I guess President Truman, a decent piano player, might have done had he ever been given the royal command, but other than Harry - and his daughter, Margaret, who played professionally (but not very capably) before taking to … [Read more...]
Stand by for the u-turn
Life has its little ups and downs, but seldom so extreme as the ones that have just hit the composer Brett Dean. Last month, the Australian government announced it was closing down the National Academy of Music, of which Dean is director. Dean, 47, had given up playing viola in Simon Rattle's Berlin Philharmonic to help raise the next generation of Australian musicians in a so-called 'centre of excellence'. But a new Labour government, suspicious of elitism, … [Read more...]

Recent Comments
Jeffrey Biegel on Hot: Russian site runs Detroit concert livecast with Ford cash
The Detroit Symphony Orchestra has always been a respected and world class orchestra, with world class conductors. One dream...GW on Opera house is ‘charged $9,000 to quote newspaper reviews’. Surely not…
This has absolutely nothing to do with reporting on the Wulff case. This is a business-side effort to create...Jan on Honour at last for the English diva who made Danny Boy a world favourite
Thank you for posting Deanna. Beautiful song, did not know is was from 1915. Beautiful voice of Deanna Durbin. I'am an...Roy Lisker on Boston’s Zander scandal: Now NEC alumni petition for his reinstatement
I was saddened to read that Benjamin Zander had "apologized" for doing nothing more incorrect than using the services (not...william osborne on Latest from Philadelphia bankruptcy crisis: it’s Catch-22
The issue isn’t just one year’s worth of payments to the pension fund, but rather the payments for many years...william osborne on Opera house is ‘charged $9,000 to quote newspaper reviews’. Surely not…
That’s what I mean. This FAZ policy is new, provocative, and breaks entirely from international norms. It is...Terry van Vliet on Honour at last for the English diva who made Danny Boy a world favourite
Or Dame Elisabetth Schwarzkopf'?Michael Comins on Latest from Philadelphia bankruptcy crisis: it’s Catch-22
Comparing Philly to Detroit is like comparing apples to autos. Detroit kept its AFM defined benefit pension and did not...Simon on Opera house is ‘charged $9,000 to quote newspaper reviews’. Surely not…
They won't try because they need the press. German media, especially print, are very determined in pursuing their own interest...Norman Lebrecht on NY Phil Twitter feed loses the plot
He made it sound so duuuuulll