• Home
  • About
    • Out There
    • Jeff Weinstein
    • Contact
    • Archives
  • AJBlog Central
  • ArtsJournal

Out There

Jeff Weinstein's Cultural Mixology

Unexpected Ode to Joan Blondell

January 21, 2008 by Jeff Weinstein

Joan_Blondell.jpg

Remember my forgotten man
You put a rifle in his hand
You sent him far away
You shouted, “Hip, hooray!”
But look at him today.

Nothing, I repeat, nothing in the cowardly realm of popular culture makes me weep the way the sinfully uncelebrated Joan Blondell does when she sings these lyrics in the final set-piece of Busby Berkeley’s Gold Diggers of 1933.
I happened to catch the genius Berkeley’s Footlight Parade on Turner Classic Movies, and its irrepressible Depression bounce (how the boys and girls of the chorus drop everything and dash when crates of food arrive) led me to the library and its trove of Busby DVDs. I put on the first of his Gold Diggers … and was a goner.
That old movie, the kind anyone then would buy a ticket to see, actually found the face of government heartlessness toward the country’s broke and rejected World War vets, and spat on it. And not with Jon Stewart manipulation or HBO cynicism. With a voice, an expressive, passionate musical voice.
Audiences loved the art and the nerve of it — and still would.
Al Dubin wrote the bread-line words and Harry Warren the minor-key music of “Remember My Forgotten Man.” Tell me, do Out There readers know how riveting entertainment can be when it is knit into some kind of unforeseen, imaginative truth? All my life I have loved movies and TV because they told me how to grab the most important ideas and feelings from the gutter. “Million Dollar Movie,” the TCM of its time, was my premier childhood classroom. But now, popular films in particular are flying fast from any connection to honesty or risk.
forgottenman.jpg
Scene from the “My Forgotten Man” number in Gold Diggers of 1933. Joan, at right, plays a “working girl.”
I grew up not with parents, but in front of a screen. I haven’t bought a ticket to see a movie in almost a year. Vivacious Blondell, who could act Saturn rings around the likes of phony Joan Crawford and unintentionally best predictable partner Cagney, had that “thing” that enabled her to stride the gulf between role and real. Those vintage images and crackling sounds she made have more blood and guts in them than any nightly Fox newscast. Where is the voice that will nail war now?
If you need any argument for the import of the cultural arts, she is it.
* * *
Click here for the “My Forgotten Man” number. The astounding second singer of the song is an uncredited Etta Moten, who’s also the “Brazilian” who warbles “The Carioca” in Flying Down to Rio as a newly coupled Fred and Ginger burn up the floor.
Later a radio journalist, Moten was the first African American to sing at the White House when, in 1934, Eleanor Roosevelt invited her to reprise “My Forgotten Man” for FDR’s birthday. Moten played Bess in the 1942 revival of Porgy and Bess at the request of George Gershwin, who reportedly wrote the role with her in mind.
She refused to sing the word nigger, which brother Ira later removed from the libretto.
etta%20moten.jpg
* * *
For an automatic alert when there is a new Out There post, email jiweinste@aol.com.

Filed Under: main

Comments

  1. David Ehrenstein says

    January 26, 2008 at 2:11 pm

    Joan Blondell went out in a blaze of cinematic glory. Her last role was as the dyspepetic playwright in Cassavetes’ Opening Night.

  2. Rick Pennock says

    December 11, 2008 at 1:57 pm

    Joan Blondell wasa as special as the day she passed. She left us on Christmas day 1979.
    Just A Thought
    Snow falling, it is December.
    Cold day followed into a cold night.
    The light from the silver screen is fading.
    But, the images of you are not.
    Morning comes and you are gone.
    The star you were, now shines bright over the sky
    One journey, now becomes another.
    The glitter and the limelight may have gone long ago.
    But, you marched on to be a mother, a friend, and a mentor.
    Looking back through black and white.
    The color of your life comes through.
    Transforming the room to silence.
    A mold had been broken, a image comes to life.
    You could stand out anywhere.
    Even in a crowded room.
    That glow around you, Set you apart.
    Even though your gone, the glow shall burn forever.
    As the snow falls you are remembered.
    In the storm there’s a light.
    It’s that star burning ever so bright.
    Shining down bringing life.
    To that once faded silver screen.
    On Christmas Day.
    Just a thought.
    You are not forgotten
    On this special day.
    This is for you Joan.

Jeff Weinstein

Based in New York, I've been an editor of arts coverage at New York's "Soho Weekly News" (1977-79); of visual arts and architecture criticism and much else at the "Village Voice" (1981-95, with a stint as managing editor of "Artforum"); of the fine arts at the "Philadelphia Inquirer" (1997-2006); of arts and culture at "Bloomberg News" (2006-07). Until recently... Read More…

Out There

The media make a potentially fatal mistake by dividing arts coverage into high and low, old and young, and by trivializing our passionate attraction to things. In Out There I propose that all creative expression has the potential to be both … [Read More...]

[DISPLAY_ACURAX_ICONS]

@JeffWeinstein

Tweets by @jeffweinstein

Recently & Elsewhere

I wrote and narrated a Daylight Magazine slideshow (click on "Read more" below to access it and the rest), an appreciation of the late photographer Milton Rogovin. Also one about the late photographer Helen Levitt. To go back in time, kindly click … [Read More...]

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Jeff Weinstein on The Thursday Store, and a Dream: “And a happy one to you, Elizabeth. Funny that those Catskill eggs didn’t smash.” Dec 31, 14:28
  • Elizabeth Zimmer on The Thursday Store, and a Dream: “I love the tone of this. My grandmother was a farmer in the Catskills. She’ sold eggs, and would mail…” Dec 31, 08:26
  • Jeff Weinstein on The Thursday Store, and a Dream: “Hope I see you too. Thanks!” Dec 31, 02:46
  • Carol Felsenthal on The Thursday Store, and a Dream: “There’s something to be said for staying awhile; for watching the evolution of a neighborhood, from the same building, same…” Dec 30, 18:23
  • Meredith Brody on The Thursday Store, and a Dream: “Such a lovely piece, dear Jeff Weinstein. Such a great picture. I’m overwhelmed by memories. Hope that you and your…” Dec 30, 15:43
Return to top of page

an ArtsJournal blog

This blog published under a Creative Commons license

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in