Castiglione Casting: Auctioned "Chinese" Bronzes, Sought By China, Likely Italian-Designed

Thumbnail image for Chan.jpg
Jackie Chan, repatriation fighter

Calling the two 18th-century Qing Dynasty bronzes of a rat and rabbit, auctioned yesterday by Christie's, "Chinese bronzes" (as I did in yesterday's post) is a bit of a misnomer.

According to Christie's catalogue entry:

These superb and remarkably realistic heads were almost certainly designed by Giuseppe Castiglione [an Italian Jesuit missionary living in China]. Clear similarities can be seen, for example, between the style of the bronze head of the monkey from the clepsydra (sold by Christie's Hong Kong in April 2000) and that of the animal in the painting "A White Monkey" by Castiglione and now in the National Palace Museum in Taipei.
Although the looting of the Summer Palace in Beijing, to which these sculptures belonged, was deplorable, I think it's legitimate to question why China has chosen to pick an international fight over these objects---not antiquities, not by a Chinese sculptor, pillaged almost 150 years ago. Even ardent repatriationists recognize that source countries' claims, for the most part, should be subject to a cutoff date. Most objects illegally removed from the source country before that date should be granted repose, or thousands of pieces would be flying around the world. The 1860 date of the pillage of the Summer Palace would seem to predate any reasonable cutoff.

Even Patty Gerstenblith, a American lawyer specializing in international cultural property issues, who has become journalists' go-to person for pithy quotes calling for repatriation of just about everything, said this to the NY Times about these bronzes:

My view is this was looted, but it would be difficult to get that legally back. But it's got great historical significance and ought to be returned.
Undaunted by the legal obstacles to its objective, China is asserting its position any way it can---posture that some attribute to China's anger over French President Sarkozy's support for Tibetan rights during last year's Olympics in Beijing.

The seller of the objects, Pierre Bergé, had provocatively promised to relinquish the rat and rabbit to China "in exchange for Chinese human rights guarantees and permission for the exiled spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, to return to Tibet," as Maureen Fan of the Washington Post reported. (That offer was a non-starter.)

Xinhua, the Chinese news agency, today quotes China's State Administration of Cultural Heritage as declaring that this incident had "damaged Chinese citizens' cultural rights and feelings and will have serious effects on Christie's development in China."

Le-Min Lim and Stephanie Wong of Bloomberg have more details on what this could mean for the auction house:

London-based Christie's must give details of the ownership and provenance of any artifacts it wants to bring into or out of China, the State Administration of Cultural Heritage [SACH] said today in a statement on its website. [The "English" button on that website didn't work for me.] Antiques that are without papers won't be allowed to enter or leave....China's move today implies added paperwork on antiques handled by Christie's, and may make it tougher for mainland Chinese to bring home artifacts they buy from the company's auctions.
Christie's has a 23-year-old office in Hong Kong and holds auctions there in May and November. Some 12 sales are scheduled at the end of this May. When I asked Christie's if these are now in jeopardy, I received this reply from Toby Usnik, the auction house's chief spokesperson:

Christie's abides by all international and local laws affecting us in our sale jurisdictions. Christie's has a public history of cooperating with customs and government officials in the few cases where there were questions with legal ownership or cultural patrimony.

In this instance the legal ownership of the fountainheads was clearly confirmed, and we have directly and honestly engaged with SACH in discussing the YSL [Yves Saint Laurent] sale over the past months. We explained our obligation to offer the heads under a binding contract with the vendor covering the entire YSL collection. 

We continue to believe that sale by public auction offers the best opportunity for items to be repatriated as a result of worldwide exposure. Christie's remains committed to China and is sincere in our respect for the government's concerns. We stand ready to discuss the situation with SACH.
As if things weren't bad enough, Christie's may also have to mess with martial-arts star Jackie Chan (who plans to make a film about repatriation of Chinese antiquities).

Great Britain's Times quotes Chan saying this from Hong Kong about the Christie's-auctioned objects:

They remain looted items, no matter whom they were sold to. Whoever took it out [of China] is himself a thief. It was looting yesterday. It is still looting today.
At least Christie's can console itself with the stellar results of the three-day series of auctions that, if not the Sale of the (still young) Century, was a major art-market watershed. The Saint Laurent/Bergé dispersal fetched a staggering $483.84 million and was 95.5% sold by lot, and 93% sold by value.

No one's put up those kinds of numbers for a major sale since the global financial crisis began.
February 26, 2009 12:20 PM | |

About

CULTUREGRRL (Lee Rosenbaum) is the artworld's award-winning "best blog."

DK&Me1.jpg
Photo © by Jill Krementz

CULTUREGRRL SPEAKS on museum issues and ethics, arts journalism.
CONTACT ME: here.

CULTUREGRRL VIDEOS
My YouTube Channel

FIND ME ON
LinkedINn.png

FOLLOW ME ON twitter.png
________________________
more

LEE ROSENBAUM I'm a veteran cultural journalist with many pieces in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal and major art magazines. I have been a cultural contributor on New York Public Radio (WNYC and WQXR) and have provided arts commentary on NPR and public radio stations in Philadelphia and Los Angeles. I am a HuffPost Arts writer. I've been profiled on the PBS NewsHour with Jim Lehrer's Art Beat and in the Chicago Reader. I've appeared as an art-market commentator on BBC-TV and have published numerous Op-Ed pieces in the New York Times and Los Angeles Times. I am author of The Complete Guide to Collecting Art (Knopf) and have lectured on cultural property issues at the New Acropolis Museum and the University of Pennsylvania, on deaccessioning at at Investigative Reporters and Editors 2011 Annual Meeting, Columbia Law School, the University of Iowa and a conference of the Museum Association of New York, on museum governance and cultural property issues at Seton Hall University, on arts blogging at American University and on Smithsonian exhibition controversies at Rutgers University.

more

CONTACT ME
Write to me here.
more

Archives

Archives: 2899 entries and counting

Me Elsewhere

Highlights from my writings and broadcasts: 


MY BOOK
The Complete Guide to Collecting Art (Knopf)

MAINSTREAM MEDIA

NY TIMES ARTS & LEISURE
Two Painters: So Alike, So Different (Caravaggio/Hals)

NY TIMES OP-EDS:
For Sale: Our Permanent Collection (museum deaccessions)
Fashion Victim (Chanel at the Met)
Destroying the Museum to Save It (Barnes Foundation)
Reassembling Sundered Antiquities (Parthenon marbles)

WALL STREET JOURNAL:
American Indian Installations
Morgan Library Renovation
Virginia Museum of Fine Arts' Expansion (designed by Rick Mather)
Crisis in Art Bibliography (Getty and BHA)
Profile of the Met's Tom Campbell
Elevating American Indian Art (Nelson-Atkins)
Landesman Produces Controversy
New Modern Wing at Art Institute of Chicago
Michael Conforti Profile
Making Sales Look Stronger
Lee Krasner's "Little Image "Paintings
Ando-Designed Stone Hill Center for Conservation and Clark Exhibitions
Los Angeles' New Broad Museum of Contemporary Art
Philadelphia's New Perelman Building
The Walton Effect: Art World Is Roiled by Wal-Mart Heiress

Tricks of the Auction Trade

The Seattle Art Museum: A Work in Progress

Upside Down and Backward, Yet Tame (Boston ICA)
Edith Wharton's Library Is Now an Open Book
Extreme Makeover: Smithsonian Edition (American Art and Portrait Gallery renovation)
This Museum's Expansion is Simply Effective (Minneapolis Institute)
Truth in Booty: Coming--and Staying--Clean (antiquities controversies)
A Betrayal of Trust (NY Public Library's art sales)
The Lost Museum (MoMA's art sales)
Endangered Species (single-collector jewel-box museums)
Money in Motion (the Guggenheim's finances)
The Fine Art of Genocide? (appraisals of Hitler's art)
National Museum of the American Indian

LA TIMES OP-EDS:
Make Art Loans, Not War
Museums Can't Compete (public collecting endangered)

HUFFINGTON POST:
My columns for HuffPost Arts

PHILADELPHIA INQUIRER
Her Art Came First: Anne d'Harnoncourt's Labor of Love

ART IN AMERICA:
[Note: The AiA links, alas, are no longer active.]
Refreshing the Smithsonian (the renovated SAAM and NPG)
The Atrium That Ate the Morgan (Renzo Piano's addition)
Hot Pots and Potshots (controversies over museum antiquities)
Musings on Museums (book review of "Whose Muse?")

NPR:
Crystal Bridges controversies
Crystal Bridges Museum's $800 Million (from American Public Media)
Smithsonian's "Hide/Seek" Controversy
Sotheby's Polaroid auction (at 1:20)
AAM's Cultural Diplomacy Initiative

WQXR, NEW YORK CLASSICAL RADIO
Rising Ticket Prices
New Museum's Dakis Joannou exhibition
Modernist Abstraction Exhibitions in NYC

NEW YORK PUBLIC RADIO:
NY State's New Deaccessioning Rules
American Folk Art Museum sells building to MoMA
Art Deaccessioning: Right or Wrong?
Musical Diplomacy on "Soundcheck Smackdown"
Vermeer's "Milkmaid" at the Met
Art in the Obama White House
Museum of Arts and Design Opens
New Met Director, Brian Lehrer Show
Tom Campbell Named Met Director
Whitney Museum's Expansion
Fake Coptic Art at Brooklyn Museum
Spring '08 Art Auctions
Should Veterans or Newcomers Lead Arts Organizations?
Murakami at Brooklyn Museum
Whitney Biennial
Guggenheim Director Steps Down
Philippe de Montebello's Retirement
Fall '07 Art Auctions
Metropolitan Museum's "Age of Rembrandt" Show
Commentary on the Art Market
Tour of Sculpture Gardens, with Slideshow
Audio Commentary on the Met's New Greek and Roman Galleries
Glenn Lowry's Unorthodox Compensation Package
Commentary on Fall '07 Art Market

PHILADELPHIA PUBLIC RADIO:
Philadelphia Museum's "Gross Clinic" Deaccessions
Museums' Purchase and Sale of Eakins' Works (about one-third of the way into the program)
Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts' sale of Eakins' "The Cello Player"

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA PUBLIC RADIO
Getty Museum's antiquities scandals (at 22:38)
Getty Trust's New President, James Cuno (at 12:10)
Getty and LA MOCA Directorship Controversies (at 44:30)
Reminiscences about James Wood (at 19:28)

BBC-TV:
Impressionist/Modern Auction at Sotheby's

more of me elsewhere

Blogroll

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by CultureGrrl published on February 26, 2009 12:20 PM.

Rare Chinese Bronzes Fetch $20.12 Million Each at Christie’s Bravura French Auction was the previous entry in this blog.

Resourceful Rishel: Philadelphia’s Sensational "Cézanne and Beyond" is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

AJ Blogs

AJBlogCentral | rss

culture
About Last Night
Terry Teachout on the arts in New York City
Artful Manager
Andrew Taylor on the business of arts & culture
blog riley
rock culture approximately
critical difference
Laura Collins-Hughes on arts, culture and coverage
Dewey21C
Richard Kessler on arts education
diacritical
Douglas McLennan's blog
Dog Days
Dalouge Smith advocates for the Arts
Flyover
Art from the American Outback
lies like truth
Chloe Veltman on how culture will save the world
Life's a Pitch
For immediate release: the arts are marketable
Mind the Gap
No genre is the new genre
Performance Monkey
David Jays on theatre and dance
Plain English
Paul Levy measures the Angles
Real Clear Arts
Judith H. Dobrzynski on Culture
Rockwell Matters
John Rockwell on the arts
State of the Art
innovations and impediments in not-for-profit arts
Straight Up |
Jan Herman - arts, media & culture with 'tude

dance
Foot in Mouth
Apollinaire Scherr talks about dance
Seeing Things
Tobi Tobias on dance et al...

jazz
Jazz Beyond Jazz
Howard Mandel's freelance Urban Improvisation
ListenGood
Focus on New Orleans. Jazz and Other Sounds
Rifftides
Doug Ramsey on Jazz and other matters...

media
Out There
Jeff Weinstein's Cultural Mixology
Serious Popcorn
Martha Bayles on Film...

classical music
Creative Destruction
Fresh ideas on building arts communities
The Future of Classical Music?
Greg Sandow performs a book-in-progress
Overflow
Harvey Sachs on music, and various digressions
PianoMorphosis
Bruce Brubaker on all things Piano
PostClassic
Kyle Gann on music after the fact
Sandow
Greg Sandow on the future of Classical Music
Slipped Disc
Norman Lebrecht on Shifting Sound Worlds
The Unanswered Question
Joe Horowitz on music

publishing
book/daddy
Jerome Weeks on Books
Quick Study
Scott McLemee on books, ideas & trash-culture ephemera

theatre
Drama Queen
Wendy Rosenfield: covering drama, onstage and off

visual
Aesthetic Grounds
Public Art, Public Space
Another Bouncing Ball
Regina Hackett takes her Art To Go
Artopia
John Perreault's art diary
CultureGrrl
Lee Rosenbaum's Cultural Commentary
Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.