Newspapers with art critics: California shines

The two best art critics still employed by a U.S. newspaper who don't work for the New York Times are both in California: Christopher Knight at the LA Times and Kenneth Baker at the SF Chronicle.

There are no art critics on staff at daily newspapers in Seattle, Chicago, Miami, Dallas and Houston, among others. The admirable Douglas Britt works for the Houston Chronicle on contract. Even though he has the output of two staffers and has brought the paper back into the national discussion, the Chronicle has not said it will restore the position.

A newspaper art critic differs from colleagues at art magazines in one essential, and it's not that the former is less savvy than the latter, although that is frequently the case. A critic at the newspaper aspires to a general audience. The chance to hook somebody with a review who's flipping pages to get somewhere else is tantalizing.

Without newspapers, those accidents appear to be less likely to happen, but there is more depth and range in each separate field, with Web sites available to run on a constant scroll across the face of cell phones.

In that context, art coverage in Golden State newspapers remains golden.

Here's Knight on MoCA. As ever he's making the case for Los Angeles:

But this is not just a promotional treasure-house show. Installed chronologically by chief curator Paul Schimmel, it also tells a story -- although one that's rarely heard. The postwar rise of American art is paired with the simultaneous rise of Los Angeles, from shallow backwater to cultural powerhouse. (more)
Kenneth Baker is more detached. He makes his case artist by artist and doesn't care about regional positioning:


Expatriate American painter Cole Morgan works like a man keeping a journal, jotting down scenes, images and incidents for a story that never gets told... The studio wall - a catchall for reminders, sketches, mementos, little visual gimmicks - may be (his) ultimate subject...Morgan's work can seem annoyingly mannered at times, but his fondness for making it never comes into doubt, a quality found too rarely in contemporary art. (more)

colemorgansf.jpg
Interesting that Morgan's work shares so much with SF's Squeak Carnwath. Mannered is a good word for her work as well, but Baker has come to appreciate her enough to overlook it:

Things make their way into Carnwath's paintings as they do into anyone's consciousness: by intrusion, by triggering memories and ricocheting off the mental walls of habit and fixation. (more)
squeakcarnwath.jpg
Also from Baker, bad news for the Berkeley Art Museum:

A shortage of funds has prompted UC Berkeley to abandon its plan to construct a new Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive downtown. The building, a distinctive and innovative design by Tokyo architect Toyo Ito estimated to cost $143 million, was to replace the museum's present, seismically endangered quarters on Bancroft Way, completed in 1970. (more)

Baker and Knight are stellar, but also solid is Robert Pincus at the San Diego Union-Tribune. His recent piece on Tara Donovan says it all.

Sample:

The question -- How did she do it? -- has different facets to it. There's the technical aspects of how to get thousands of pins to form a cube without adhesives (density and gravity are what does the remarkable trick) and how thousands of straws stay in place when stacked (some adhesive here).

But there is also the bigger issue: How are these works so much greater than the sum of their parts? The best word for it might be alchemy. A wall of straws, "Haze," doesn't look like straws -- it resembles a meteorological event, shifting clouds or fog. Scotch tape becomes a field of delicate forms, looking like a bed of underwater flora. (more)

Knight, Baker and Pincus are all veterans. Britt in Houston represents critics of the next generation. For them, there is no room in the old media landscape, and the new can't come soon enough.
November 18, 2009 9:22 PM | | Comments (4) |

4 Comments

Diana. Paul Schimmel is a brilliant curator. As far as Chris Burden being my buddy, I should be so lucky. Christopher Knight is one-sided? He's a critic. The side from which he sees things is his own. I'll take him over a 100 more reasonable others.

Christopher Knight's nickname in LA is Christopher Knightmare. He is totally linked with Schimmel and your buddy Burden and is very one-sided in his criticism.

Well observed, Regina!
General news media does have a different audience, and arts writers there necessarily have broader foci. Not only does Chris Knight cover gallery and museum exhibitions, he reviews non-profit spaces and public art, giving both professional insight and general access to multiple aspects of contemporary art news.

And as a lapsed Houstonian, I experienced Doug Britt's importance in the Houston scene. He writes about public art, performances, art conferences and alternative spaces as well as the commercial gallery scene. He understands his profession and writes very well.

The notion of what comprises art news and art criticism for a general readership is key to the growth of contemporary art efforts in all regions.

I agree about Kenneth Baker being one of the best and last newspaper critics left writing. He recently wrote a very perceptive review about Anne Appleby's recent show in San Francisco at Paule Anglim Gallery.

Comparing Appleby, as she often is, to Brice Marden, Baker wrote:

"The two artists continue to address a common difficulty: how to project personal meaning into abstraction without expressionism.

But the materialist quality common to Marden's early and Appleby's recent work may encourage people to misread hers, which behaves very differently from his. Briefly, Marden's oil and wax pictures respond to light but do not seem to emanate it. Appleby's do both."

That is, to my mind, a very perceptive response to these two very good artists who have worked in similar materials but with subtly different results.

Leave a comment

About

Another Bouncing Ball
This blog continues Art To Go, which I wrote as the art critic for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, beginning at the end of 2007 and continuing through March 15, 2009. ABB is an exploration of art in Seattle that extends outward, both geographically and by topic, touching on art, politics, literature, dance and whatever it is that the cat drags in. Its title comes from a poem by Delmore Schwartz, The Ballad of the Children of the Czar, specifically, "The ground on which the ball bounces/ Is another bouncing ball."
more

Regina Hackett ... is the former art critic for the former Seattle P-I. I loved that job every day, but it's gone and I've moved on. As they say in the movies, to infinity and beyond.
more

Contact me Click here to send me an email, or email me directly at anotherbb(at)gmail.com. My mailing address is 300 Queen Anne Ave. N. Seattle, WA 98109
more

Archives

Archives: 943 entries and counting

Recent Comments

Recent Assets

  • claytoncotterboots.jpg
  • claytoncotteralbro.jpg
  • danwebbfortres.jpg
  • christianehaaseghost.jpg
  • stormtharp.jpg
  • andreasalvinocloset.jpg
  • trevorjohnsonstyro.jpg
  • SharonArnoldleftdang.jpg
  • evahessehangup.jpg
  • sharonarnoldadddetal.jpg

Blogroll

At the Frye: The Old, Weird America: Folk Themes in Contemporary Art. Through Jan. 3.

Old, Weird America reviews on this blog: Godforsaken Curios; Margaret Kilgallen owns Main Street; Sam Durant gives thanks, and If Northwest artists had been in The Old, Weird America, it would have been a stronger show.


SEATTLE (AND REGIONAL) ART BLOGS


· Art and Politics Now

· Artblog +

. Artdish

· Art Scatter

· Best Of

. Dimensions Variable

. Eva Lake

. Getting to Know You Better 

. Go Head On

· Hank

. Idaho Arts Quarterly

· (incli)NATION

. John Boylan's Conversations

. jouissance

. Meaning in Art

. Nine Thermidor

. O My God Seattle

. Oregon Art Live

· Olympia Dumpster Divers

. Pacific Standard

· Page 291

· Peripheral Vision

. Port

. Power Slice

. Redefine

· Round About Seattle

. Seattle Art Blog

. Seattle Arts and Culture

SOAP

. Something To Say

· Stranger - Visual Art

. Teen Tix

· That's A Negative

. Telephone Room

· To Fear It Is To Know It

· Translinguistic Other

. Vroom Journal


SEATTLE GALLERIES


· Ambach & Rice

. Cairo

· Catherine Person

· Crawl Space

. Davidson Galleries

. Facere (Jewelry)

. Fetherston

. Flatcolor

. Form/Space Atelier

. Foster/White

· Francine Seders

. Friesen

· G. Gibson

· Gallery I/M/A

. Gossamer Collective

· Greg Kucera

. Grover Thurston

· Grey

· James Harris

. Joe Bar

· Howard House

· Lawrimore Project

· Martin-Zambito

· Linda Hodges

· Lisa Harris Gallery

. OHGE Ltd

· Ouch My Eye

· Platform

· Punch

· Roq La Rue

· Soil

· Some Space

· Traver

  Vermillion

· Wall of Sound

. Winston Wachter

· Woodside/Braseth


REGIONAL ART SPACES


· Center on Contemporary Art

. Ditch Projects

· Gallery 4Culture

· Hedreen Gallery

· Kirkland Arts Center

· Open Satellite

· Photographic Center Northwest

· Suyama Space

· Western Bridge

· Wright Exhibition Space (No Web Site)

· Columbia City


SEATTLE (AND REGIONAL) ART MUSEUMS


· Bellevue Arts Museum

· Frye Art Museum

· Henry Art Gallery

· Museum of Contemporary Craft

· Museum of Northwest Art

· Portland Art Museum

· Seattle Art Museum

· Tacoma Art Museum

· Vancouver Art Gallery

· Whatcom Museum of History and Art


SEATTLE (AND REGIONAL) ARTIST WEBSITES

 · Juan Alonso

· Julie Alpert

. Julie Alexander

. Heidi Anderson

. Holly Andres

. Rick Araluce

. Sharon Arnold

· Sonny Assu

· Brad Atkins

· Nola Avienne

· Aaron Bagley

· Crystal Barbre

· Grant Barnhart

· Bo Bartlett

· Debra Baxter

· Linda Beaumont

· Justin Colt Beckman

. Jessica Bender

· Gala Bent

· Zack Bent

· Gretchen Bennett

· Mark Bennion

· Leo Saul Berk

. Zalman Berkowtiz

· John Berry

· Evan Blackwell

. Warner Blake

· Jim Blanchard

. Sonja Blomdahl

. Susanna Bluhm

· Scott Bokma

· Gloria Bornstein

· Andrew Breen

. Jana Brevick

· Sally Brock

· Nicholas Brown

· Matt Browning

· Brims (Brian Sims)

. Christopher Buening

· Buddy Bunting

· Patrick Burke

· Jennifer Campbell

. Daniel A. Carrillo

· Jenny Zoe Casey

. Laura Castellanos

· Michael Cepress

· Dawn Cerny

· Laura Chamberlin

· Lauri Chambers

· Art Chantry

. Jaq Chartier

· Diem Chau

· Dale Chihuly

· Close Enough Engineering

· Catherine Cook

. Laura Corsiglia

· Chris Crites

· Tim Cross

· Clayton Cusak

· Michael Dailey

· Drew Daly

· Steve Davis

. Jack Daws

· Gloria DeArcangelis

· Pat De Caro

. Jeff DeGolier

· Tom DeGroot

· John Dempcy

· Barbara De Pirro

· Linda Davidson

· Marita Dingus

· Marc Dombrosky

. Garek Druss

. Ann Duffy

. Annie Duffy

· Warren Dykeman

. Eakins & Dombrosky

· Jeremy E. Eaton

· Betsy Eby

. Jesse Edwards

· Eric Eley

· Eric Elliott

· Tori Ellison

· William E Elston

· Chris Engman

· erico

· Dennis Evans

· Leiv Fagereng

· Gary Faigin

· Diana Falchuk

· John Feodorov

· Fire Retard Ants

· Kathe Fraga

· Laura Fritz

· Alan Fulle

· Karen Ganz

· Ann Gardner

· Geoff Garza

· Christopher Gay

. Ford Gilbreath

. Lisa Gilley

. Kathryn A. Glowen

· David N. Goldberg

· Wynne Greenwood

· Mandy Greer

· Cable Griffith

· Jessixa Grilihas

· Lauren Grossman

· Noah Grussgott

· Troy Gua

· Julia Haack

· Patricia Hagen

. Robert Hardgrave

· Damion Hayes

. Blake Haygood

· Victoria Haven

· Michael James Hawk

· Blake Haygood

· Jenny Heishman

· Richard Heisler

· Harrison Higgs

. Jesse Higman

· Harold Hollingsworth

· Gail Howard

· Jason Huff

. Amy Huddleston

· Alan Hurley

· Etsuko Ichikawa

· Elizabeth Jameson

· Reilly Jensen

. Victoria Johnson

· Jody Joldersma

· Fay Jones

· Robert C. Jones

· Tomiko Jones

· Emilia Kallock

. Shaun Kardinal

. Sarah Kavage

· Alison Keogh

· Billy King

· Sheila Klein

. Paul Komada

· Charles Krafft

· Carolyn Krieg

· Jane Lackey

· Eva Lake

· Deborah Faye Lawrence

· Lead Pencil

· Ingrid Lahti

· Molly Landreth

· Isaac Layman

· Mike Leavitt

· Susie J. Lee

· Rich Lehl

. Walter Lieberman

· Margie Livingston

· Hugo Ludena

· Greg Lukens

· Spike Mafford

· Sam Magnotto

. Alison Manch

. Jeremy Mangan

· Dante Marioni

. Richard Marquis

. Robert Masa

. Anne Mathern

· Rachel Maxi

· Roy McMakin

. Jennifer McNeely

· Nancy Mee

· Jesse Paul Miller

· Robert Mirenzi

. Erin Morrison

. Jacques Moitoret

. Ryan Molenkamp

· Saya Moriyasu

· William Morris

· Fred Muram

· Yuki Nakamura

. Matt Neyens

· Ries Niemi

· Barbara Noah

· T J Norris (unblogged)

· Nicolas Nyland

. Andrew O'Brien

· Oregon Department of Kick Ass

. Shaw Osha

· Joseph Park

· Eugene Parnell

· Chauney Peck

· Mary Ann Peters

. Christian Petersen

· Charles Peterson

· Alexis M. Pike

· Emily Pothast

· Jean Prominski

· Kate Protage

. Kristen T. Ramirez

· Demi Raven

· Rebecca Raven

. Kait Rhoads

· Tivon Rice

. Jane Richlovsky

· Susan Robb

. Patrick Rock

. Lynda K. Rockwood

· Joan Stuart Ross

. Richard Royal

· Ginny Ruffner

· Ariana Page Russell

. Serrah Russell

· Harriet Sanderson

· Elizabeth Sandvig

. Cathy Sarkowsky

· Adam Satushek

. John Schuh

· Alex Schweder

. Jena Scott

· SeaShow

· Holly Senn

· Mike Simi

. Garric Simonsen

· Buster Simpson

· Preston Singletary

. Catherine Eaton Skinner

. Sabrina Small

· Derin Smith

· Adam Sorenson

· Michael Spafford

. Lucas Spivey

· Kenneth Susynski

· suttonberesculler

· CJ Swanson

· Akio Takamori

· Kellie Talbot

. 39 Forks

. Cappy Thompson

. Jennifer Towner

· Timea Tihanyi

· Alice Tippit

· Cara Tomlinson

. Christian van Minnen

. Joey Veltkamp

. Vital 5 Productions

· wabearchub

· Laura Ward

. Brent Watanabe

· Darren Waterston

· Dan Webb

· Alice Wheeler

. Blair Wilson

· Brad Winchester

. Randy Wood

· Shawn Wolfe

. Chris White

· XOM

. YaChin You

· Yunko Yamamoto

· Claude Zervas

· Ellen Ziegler

. Sarah Zin

· Susan Zoccola

. Robert Francis Zverina

· Jennifer Zwick


EVERYWHERE ELSE BLOG (And Beyond Blog) LINKS


· An Aesthete's Lament

· ANABA

· ARTADOX

. Art As Authority

. ArtBabble

. Artblog

. Artlog

. Art Baloney Blog

· Art Fag City

. Artillery

· Artinfo

· Art Or Idiocy?

· Art Vent

· Avant Guardian

. Bad At Sports

· Bay Area Art Quake!

· Best of 3

. Big, Red & Shiny

· Bloggy

· Brief Epigrams

. Brooklyn Rail

. Contemporary Art Daily

· C-Monster

. Culture Monster (LA TIMES)

· Contrariwise: Literary Tattoos

· Culture Grrl

· Daily Campello

· Daily Serving

. Dancing Perfectly Free

· Dinosaurs and Robots

· Eco Art Blog

· Ekosystem

· Everything Everywhere All Of The Time

· Exhibitionist

· Expanded Field

· Exposures

. Eyeteeth

· Roberta Fallon/Libby Rosof

. Flavorpill

. Flyp (art)

· foto08

. For Your Art

· Freese

. Geek Mythology

. Glasstire

. Graphic Witness

· Greg.Org

· Heart As Arena

. Hungry Hyena

. Hello Beautiful

· I Heart Photograph

· Jeff Weinstein: Out There

· Jonathan Jones

. Kung Fu Art Critic

· Leap Into The Void

· Looking Around

. Los Angeles County Museum On Fire

· Lost And Found Photos

. Luminal Schema

· Luminous Lint

· Lance Mannion

· Loreto Martin

· Joanne Mattera

· Modern Art Obsession

· Modern Art Notes

· Modern Kicks

. Nat Creole

. New Art

· NEWSgrist

. New.York.Art.Crit

. of note

. Oly's Musings

· Over The Net

. Real Clear Arts

· Rhizome

. Slow Muse

. Sweet Station

· Zoe Strauss

. Sustainable Practice in the Arts

. This Isn't Happiness

· 1000 Words Photography

· Tomorrow Museum

. Triple Canopy

· Trrill

· Two Coats of Paint

· unBLOGGED

. Unedit My Heart

· Urban Honking

. View On Canadian Art

· VVORK

· Vroom Journal

. WeArePhotography

· James Wagner

. Web Street

· We Make Money Not Art

· Edward_Winkleman

· Wooster Collective

. Wrong Distance



About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Another Bouncing Ball published on November 18, 2009 9:22 PM.

Support Suyama Space was the previous entry in this blog.

Sympathy for soliders is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

AJ Ads

Introducing
AJ Arts Blog Ads

Now you can reach the most discerning arts blog readers on the internet. Target individual blogs or topics in the ArtsJournal ad network.

Advertise Here








AJ Blogs

AJBlogCentral | rss

culture
About Last Night
Terry Teachout on the arts in New York City
Artful Manager
Andrew Taylor on the business of arts & culture
blog riley
rock culture approximately
critical difference
Laura Collins-Hughes on arts, culture and coverage
Dewey21C
Richard Kessler on arts education
diacritical
Douglas McLennan's blog
Dog Days
Dalouge Smith advocates for the Arts
Flyover
Art from the American Outback
Life's a Pitch
For immediate release: the arts are marketable
Mind the Gap
No genre is the new genre
Performance Monkey
David Jays on theatre and dance
Plain English
Paul Levy measures the Angles
Real Clear Arts
Judith H. Dobrzynski on Culture
Rockwell Matters
John Rockwell on the arts
Straight Up |
Jan Herman - arts, media & culture with 'tude

dance
Foot in Mouth
Apollinaire Scherr talks about dance
Seeing Things
Tobi Tobias on dance et al...

jazz
Jazz Beyond Jazz
Howard Mandel's freelance Urban Improvisation
ListenGood
Focus on New Orleans. Jazz and Other Sounds
Rifftides
Doug Ramsey on Jazz and other matters...

media
Out There
Jeff Weinstein's Cultural Mixology
Serious Popcorn
Martha Bayles on Film...

classical music
Creative Destruction
Fresh ideas on building arts communities
The Future of Classical Music?
Greg Sandow performs a book-in-progress
On the Record
Exploring Orchestras w/ Henry Fogel
Overflow
Harvey Sachs on music, and various digressions
PianoMorphosis
Bruce Brubaker on all things Piano
PostClassic
Kyle Gann on music after the fact
Sandow
Greg Sandow on the future of Classical Music
Slipped Disc
Norman Lebrecht on Shifting Sound Worlds

publishing
book/daddy
Jerome Weeks on Books
Quick Study
Scott McLemee on books, ideas & trash-culture ephemera

theatre
Drama Queen
Wendy Rosenfield: covering drama, onstage and off
lies like truth
Chloe Veltman on how culture will save the world

visual
Aesthetic Grounds
Public Art, Public Space
Another Bouncing Ball
Regina Hackett takes her Art To Go
Artopia
John Perreault's art diary
CultureGrrl
Lee Rosenbaum's Cultural Commentary
Modern Art Notes
Tyler Green's modern & contemporary art blog
Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.