AJ Logo an ARTSJOURNAL weblog | ArtsJournal Home | AJ Blog Central

« OGIC: Excuses, excuses | Main | TT: Letters to the blogosphere »

November 7, 2003

TT: We get letters

Here are four recent letters to "About Last Night" that caught my eye:

  • "I doubt there'll be a time when ‘the printed book gives way, as in time it surely must, to the hand-held electronic book-reading device.' A printed book gives tactile pleasure--the heft of it, the texture of the pages, the feel of turning them one by one--that an electronic book never could. I'm reminded of the entire-meal-in-a-pill in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, the one that turns Violet into a huge blueberry. Such a pill would never become popular, because there are elements to eating other than flavor, elements that the pill couldn't reproduce. I'd make a parallel argument for the printed book over the electronic one....

    "You're right about the end of the record album, though."

  • "I think it's entirely right and proper to be concerned about the public's willingness to pay attention to anything for very long--I know more than enough teachers to see the problem frequently illustrated. And yet...

    "Peter Jackson and his crew are packing them into theatres with movies more than three hours long, and then selling them (by which I mean ‘us', since I'm part of this crowd) DVDs that take the running time up to four hours. The brothers Wachowski aren't having any problems with public interest in movies well over two hours long. Nor are directors as diverse as Bryan Singer, George Lucas, and Ang Lee.

    "But it's not just a matter of the movie pendulum being way over toward the side marked ‘will sit long hours for movies we like'. Boxed sets are doing great business in music and DVDs. Complete Anything collections move well. Likewise, the boom in manga is the result of a bunch of teenagers finding that they're quite willing to commit to many, many volumes of series that hook their attention....

    "The passing of the album in music therefore seems less than inevitable to me, and less than a harbinger of general doom in spite of that crabbed little part of my soul eager to say ‘Ha ha, I knew it, the kids are NOT all right.' It's just that, for whatever reason(s), the way albums are put together doesn't seem to grab the attention or sympathy of enough listeners. There's presumably room for someone to do what's been done in film and graphic storytelling and make long works engaging again."

  • "I read what you wrote in the WSJ [about The Producers] and I have to say, I think you're wrong. I'm 21, and my friends and I constantly watch older comedies. To be perfectly honest, they're funnier than anything that comes out now. The Producers, Blazing Saddles, History of the World Part I.....they're a different kind of funny than movies that come out now. It's more solid, something you're going to remember after you get out of the theater, something you'll quote to someone or think to yourself and laugh at random....

    "The fact that they don't make movies like that anymore is a reflection of the poor taste of the current generation of Hollywood people. Don't go pinning their poor taste on the rest of the country."

  • "Your essay about The Producers reminded me of something sad. In the days after September 11, when Rudy Giuliani was on TV, he was trying to encourage people to come to New York City. As a joke he said ‘You can even get tickets to The Producers.' That will probably be part of the history of that show, forever.

    "When The Producers first came to Broadway, I always thought that what was nostalgia for my generation was actually part of my parent's victory celebration. After a long horrible war, this was the final insult to the Nazis. I was too young to understand what my parents were laughing at. But they were happy and that was fine with me."

    "How strange that this show, in the movies and on stage should mark the end of one world war and the beginning of another."

    In case you didn't know it, smart people read this blog.

    Posted November 7, 2003 12:27 PM

    Tell A Friend

    Email this entry to:


    Your email address:


    Message (optional):














  •